Okay I'm going to sound like a complete idiot for saying this probably, but even though I love her, I can't hear her name or see it or even look at her without thinking of one of the little kids that was in The Baby-Sitters Club Books....Charlotte Johansson

Yes I'm utterly humiliated AND showing my youth.
I remember her in The Horse Whisperer.....I think she's cute but I can't picture her making out with Benicio del Toro, which she allegedly did.