I am split when it comes to the issue of alcohol in glo houses. Everything to me can be handled if the right people are in charge. Unfortuntately, you have to assume when it comes to fraternities and sororities, this is not the case. I have thought a lot about the idea of making houses dry. The would be less of a mess, no more holes in the walls and beer and puke all over. And plus, the liability issue has been elimiated. Sounds great. Yep, except for one thing, you haven't done anything productive to deal with the problem still. Yes, the physical differences in your chapter house will improve (until the brotherhood comes home loaded and feels like partying some more!), but what about the real problem with alcohol? All you've really said is "Don't drink here."
The liability issue still exists. What, just because you sponsored the activity at a 3rd party vendor, you are relieved of all risk managment involved? Wrong, you can still be sued and your fraternity is still not off the hook if someone gets injured or dies. Trust me, lawsuits will find a way to make everyone involved pay, nothing is a safe guarantee. And even if you miraculously do get out alive, the press will be waiting to paint a wholesome image for you to take with you and your organization for a couple year, inncoent or not
My opinion, and I've said the many times before, you need to get involved and educate your members about the risks and dangers with alcohol and any other type of substance abuse. Don't push the problem away, take responsibility for it and do something about it. You can't just assume that dry housing will eliminate the risks. Look into tips training, have the local police deparment give a lecture or discussion with your members. You can save lives and still have a good time at your house if everyone is prepared and well-informed.
RUgreek