I think most will like it, and may think I'm nuts for saying it looks dated, but I said the same thing about the new philanthropy logo when it was rolled out.
I think that is what happens when you are working with a non-profit and don't have the budgets of a corporate branding campaign. Although I will say the ADPi re-brand for 150th was dead-on and quite good. The people doing all of this work are, after all, volunteers, and typically don't have a graphics background. We appreciate their volunteerism though-- it keeps things moving and keeps pushing us forward. These programs wouldn't happen at all without them! Design can be refined over time.
Again, just covering myself and praising the tech committee and phil. committee for their time and efforts by saying this is just constructive criticism of someone who has worked in print and online design. IE: For a contrast of what I think IS good design, check out the new UF sorority web sites that have been designed by multimedia companies. Excellent recruitment tools, great design and very appealing. The things you can do when you know what you want and budget for it!
