I usually just get my mascara from the free gifts with purchase at Macy's. I don't go thru it quick enough to actually buy it.
I did like Clinique's waterproof mascara. I didn't wear it as much because I, for some reason, have really bad experiences with eye makeup remover... so I can't always take it off.
I don't wear it much during the summer because my eyes itch from allergies and I end up with irritated eyes.