07-14-2004, 03:19 PM
|
|
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DolphinChicaDDD
Ooo- good one. I never thought about that.
I remember reading somewhere that someone thinks there was someone else in Godric's Hallow the night that Voldey came to kill the Potters...and that person was Snape.
But I don't think Snape was there to try and kill Harry/Potters. I think he was there to try to save Harry/Potters.
If you look carefully at what Harry "remembers" during the lessons on the Patronus charm (in PoA)before his mother died, the word choice sounds alot like Snape. For example, the voice (now mind you, we're never told its Voldemort; we all just assume, which makes an ass of you and me) says "Stand aside. Stand aside, girl!" After that Harry hears his father say "Its him." I know somewhere else in one of the books, the voice/voldemort says "give him to me silly girl".
Who else do we know that says, "silly girl" quite often? Snape when he is referring to Herminonie.
Deep down, I believe Snape is a good guy. I also think he is going to die, because I think he is the one Voldemort is talking about in GoF (the one who has left his side forever, he will be killed). Tying in with Lady Pi Phi's theory, Godiric's Hollow might have been the turning point of Snape's Death Eater days. He found out Voldey was going to try and kill the Potters. Instead, he tries to go and save Harry, Lilly/James don't trust Snape (don't blame them, I wouldn't; because at that point he is a known Death Eater), Snape bounces before Voldy shows up, the rest we know.
I think THAT is why Dumbledore trusts Snape so much. He tried to save Harry before.
Right now, this is very sketchy. Later tonight, I'll try and clarify somethings by actually going through the books and trying to remember where I read that idea. I only have an hour for lunch, cleary not nearly enough time to put out a proper theory on HP. Just wanted to throw that out there for now.
|
OOH. I like it. That would make a lot of sense.
|