Matthew, hands down.
I never really *liked* Charlie (I use that term in the sense that I didn't want him to be the final guy), so I was so excited to see him get out of the limo first that night so long ago
I almost started crying the minute Matthew got out tonight...the only upside I can see is if he'd agree to be the bachelor later on down the road a bit (I'd watch, but don't have the guts to audition!)