First, what does this have to do with Greek Life? No offense Billy!
Second - asking for prayers is not UNCOOL. If you're asked to pray and you don't feel comfortable with it, then don't. But deep down only you have the Lord to answer to. If you're sick of people asking you to pray then remember you thought/said that when you wish others to pray with you...
But as a true Christian I would still pray for you/with you. But just remember
Just my 2 cents and I don't wish to get flammed for my opinions.