These are great!
Back in the day I had a crush on....
--Dean Cain (a la Lois and Clark Days...my best friend and I would "analyze" every show)
--Jordan Knight
--Pete Sampras
--Jeff Blauser (ex-Braves baseball player...my family constantly made fun of me for this!)
--Tom Cruise
--Mark Paul Gosslear
--Patrick Swayze (when he was in Dirty Dancing)
--Ben Affleck (admittedly this wasn't so far in the recent past...but it was pre J Lo days!
)
I'm sure there's more but this is enough embarrassment for now!!