Had to bump this thread back up!!
Desmond Harrington (2nd from the left) - this is the best picture I can find of him. He was in Ghost Ship and didn't do much for me then. Saw Wrong Turn the other day, and WOW!!! He's a hottie in this movie!! This picture really doesn't do him justice.
Vince Vaughn
Others who have been mentioned:
Gary Sinise
Ethan Embry
John Cusack
Colin Farrell