I'm about as hardcore a Buffett fan as they come...so stuff like Cheeseburger and Margaritaville don't even make my top 50 list.
My favorite is probably "In the Shelter" which is a song he wrote while playing in New Orleans. Another that I love is a duet he did with James Taylor about his (Buffett's) grandfather called "False Echos"
Some other favorites: Manana, Love and Luck, Changes in Lattitudes Changes in Attitudes, Life is Just a Tire Swing...
I guess you could say I belong to the
Church of Buffett, Orthodox (COBO)