How could I have forgotten my very first celeb crush, Brad Renfro??
Here he is all cute and innocent in The Cure, and now he's all bad boy and always in trouble with the law... although he frequently sports bad facial hair (why, boys, why???) he's still a stud! Except all the recent pictures I can find of him right now he looks all hungover or drugged up... ick.

And Sean Biggerstaff is SO very hot. Mrow. He could teach me Quidditch any day!
I agree with the Legolas thing - why is he SO much cuter as a long-haired elf than as a normal man?