[DeltAlum]

More thoughts on above posts:

I think it's important not to expand the hysteria by sending it in both directions.

It's not possible to be less pregnant than someone else -- you either are or you're not, but it is possible to be guilty of something to a lesser extent. That's why we have first degree murder, second degree murder and manslaughter. So, I think it might be appropriate for the penalties to be different for varying degrees of involvement.

In terms of a ten day suspension ruining someone's life. That's ridiculous. It might mean they have to go to a "lesser" college than they wanted, but that's life. They'll survive. It could be that they won't get into law school or medical school, but those are the consequences.

In terms of the junior girls getting the same suspensions, I think that's a gross injustice. They are guilty of voluntary participation in a banned event -- but not of assault and battery that I can see. Some type of penalty may be appropriate, but not the same as the seniors.

Are there really enough hours in a school day to take 10 AP classes in one year? Do they take AP electives? AP extracurriculars? Question: If you're deathly sick the day your AP test is given, how do you make it up? I'll bet there will be a way for these girls to take the test and get the credit.

The civil penalities may well be much worse than any criminal judgements. Probation or community service/fines may be likely for the criminal charges, but civil suits could be really damaging to the girls and their parents.

I could be totally incorrect (often am), but I think Good Samaritan laws are to protect people who attempt first aid or CPR. I'm not sure they apply to those who are injured trying to stop a fight. Maybe one of our lawyers can enlighten us on this. That does not, in any way, excuse those who stood by and watched this carnage, though. That's reprehensible, but I'm not sure any legal action can be taken against them.

As I understand the admissions officers, the student isn't asked questions about their character and senior year -- the guidance counselors are.

The girl who allegedly had graduated and reportedly brought a bat should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. That was obviously premeditated.

Finally, it seems to me that the school officials need to take one step back, truly evaluate the situation and weigh appropriate action. Seems to me they first tried to cover their behinds, then perhaps overreacted in some cases.