My picks are:
Chris O' Donnel-Always liked him
Antonio Sabado Jr.-
Tom Welling (Smallville)-
Marc Blucas (Riley from Buffy)-
David Boranez
Matthew McConaughey
Josh Hartnett
Micheal Rosemblum (Smallville, Sorority Boys)
New to add: Michael Owen and Johnny Wilkinson (from Navane's post)