Yeah, Amy has a good point.
The poem deserves a giant awwwwwwwww even from the boys.
Now, I am assuming she isn't unfortunate looking, so why break up with her or let her down easy?
That seems needlessly cruel as well as shooting yuorself in the foot.
Lets see, you have a pretty girl that will just come over and hava sex with you. Write you poetry. Probably do nice thingss for you, and will settle for whatever of you she can have, knowing she can't have you exclusively.
What are you a fricking moron? you keep her and are nice to her as long as you can. Duh.
You haven't made any promises so you aren't leading her on at all. And for all you know, this all the relationship she can handle from you anyway. It would be funny if you tried for more with her and she replied:" Why did you have to og and ruin it . .".
Anyway, stay and keep sleeping with her oh clueless one.