How about picture frames? You can take a 5x7 or 8x10 wooden frame and decorate it. You can glue those small craft flowers in each corner of the frame. You may be able to find your sorority flower as well.
Or, you can decorate the frame using those little greek letters you usually put on paddles. You can paint the letters in your sorority colors or just use them as is. You can also use craft paint that comes in the tube to make squigglies and other fun designs on the frame. Use your sorority colors if you like.
You can even blow up one of your favorite pictures of the two of you and put that in the frame. Or, a picture of your entire chapter.
I absolutely LOVE the wine glass idea. Pillows and photo albums are always great gifts!
------------------
Sincerity, Loyalty, Unity
Sigma Lambda Upsilon: Hasta La Muerte!