OP, I'm not quite sure if you have to absolutely wear orthotics all of the time, or what type of foot surgery you had (no need to disclose) . If you have issues related to your toes and need a roomier toe box you might want to look at Danskos. I tend to have foot problems and lower back issues if I don't wear good shoes and I'm on my feet a lot. I actually got a cute pair of closed toed clogs in a neutral color to wear with my spring sundresses if it ever stops raining. Also Taryn Rose does have good shoes although they are a bit pricey. Also depending on the norms of what's in at your school will likely dictate fashion/shoe choices. But may of the other posters had great suggestion on shoe brands to look into as well.
Also if someone is looking down at your feet which if they are then perhaps say I've had surgery on my feet and can't wear heels etc. But I wouldn't get too bent out of shape about that. I think if you wear attire to go with the campus norms hopefully the shoe thing won't even be brought up. Best of luck and I hope you keep us posted on how things go for you or if you find a good shoe option.
