BUCUTIE02, I see where you're coming from, and here's my answer to your question:

If my chapter were placed in the situation you presented, we'd probably select both of them.

Fortunately, my chapter prides itself on being a chapter that doesn't extend bids on the basis of one's looks.

We have several criteria when selecting women to receive bids, the overall impressions from the rush rounds, academic and extra-curriculars being very important ones.

One thing that I am very proud of is my chapter's diversity. There's no such thing as a "typical" sorority girl in my chapter. Whether she be skinny, full figured, affluent, not-so affluent, a goddess, or an ordinary-looking woman--she is chosen because she has the potential to embody the standards set forth in our AGD purpose.

------------------
*I'm an Alpha Gam...Yes I am, Yes I am!*