Chalk this up to being a freshman that didn't know any better.
I was at ADII and as most of you know they were founded on christian values, the sister that was rushing me had just finished telling me about that and... Having just graduated from a private parochial school, and having been pretty involved in the church I asked if they had Bible studies and stuff. My guess is that I came off sounding really religious or something (not that that's bad) and that wasn't what they were looking for. Oh well, it worked out in the end cause I ended up where I belonged