Thanks everyone for the words of encouragement!  I just got back from my first party and since I have a gigantic break between this one and the next one (my next party is at 5:30 PM!) I figured I'd type some now.
I went to 
Aquarius this morning, and I loved it!  This chapter has seriously grown on me through recruitment.  I've gone from ranking them in my bottom three the first night to seriously considering being a sister there, and I am so happy about this.  The skit was super cute and clearly showed how much they all cared about each other.  The actives I talked to were nice and I totally clicked with the last one.  I hope that I'll get to see them at prefs tomorrow!
Also on a side note the three chapters I have left have three of my favorite badges, especially 
Aquarius, so I feel like no matter which one I get I'm all set for a beautiful badge
 
ETA: Not so much a weird rush story as a weird rush observation, but there was a PNM in my party today who had what was clearly a Lilly Pulitzer Delta Gamma wristlet.  Like, had the anchors and the DG on it and everything.  I'm sure she's not actually a member of Delta Gamma but that just makes it weirder to have since she isn't one, and even weirder that she's wearing it to recruitment for other chapters!