[Cleveland]

We have a brother who has alegedly committed 6 acts of assault on his girlfriend. Two of these were on house property or on house trips and are confirmed to have happened. Each act occurs under the influence of alcohol and during the first act at the house, cops were called. No one wants to ban this girl or blackball him but me, and everyone discredits my opinion because he was my best friend and I was seeing her when they started hooking up. Honestly I don't like either of them but I feel the excessive risk they both have caused the house should give just cause for banning them both. The most recent act was this past weekend and so far his "punishment" is AA and 6 weeks prohibition of alcohol. The execs claim that since he was never told this was wrong he gets another chance and for her even though they decided that one more situation involving her and she would be banned, because she was not notified. I think this is all bull and am about to give up my exec position and possibly drop if this is not resolved. am I being too extreme or is this reasonable.