I've also seen presidents picked apart for anything/everything they did.
A few things I noticed:
1) The president should NOT be disciplining anyone on her own. Depending on your bylaws, she may be the chair of the disciplinary committee, but if she is truly disciplining people on her own, well, that would be unlike any chapter I've ever heard of.
2) Why don't the advisors don't see a problem? Are they not engaged, or is there not really a severe problem?
3) It's really possible that she's overwhelmed, and needs help, not criticism.
|