Thank you so much ladies for all of the advice! I knew I could count on GC for shoe shopping help!
So, I went shopping...and got 3 pairs of heels!! I have a shoe problem...but they were all around $35 each! I went to DSW and Marshall's, I tried the Bandolino's but they didn't quite fit me right either. But for those of you that love them, they have great deals on them at Marshalls!
Pair #1: Nice black pumps, fairly classic, nice medium-height (~2"), slightly wider heel, which I know isn't quite as fashionable right now, but is a worthwhile sacrifice to keep me feet in decent shape. Definitely can be worn again for interviews and such! And much more of a rounded toe than the picture suggests. They are Jellypop "Angel"
Pair #2: Silver strappy sandals, great to have in the closet for formal events, don't ask me why I don't already own a pair! Also about 2" high with a wider heel. They are Unlisted "Dance With Me"
Pair #3: For some reason I decided to go to Marshall's...always a bad idea because I spend way too much money there even if I don't need anything! But I got a PERFECT pair of nude pumps...I don't need them for rush, but these are a great classic staple. They are Nine West, really well made, and sooo comfortable! The leather is really soft and the insides are well padded, and the shank is flexible. Also the angle they are pitched at is really solid, so the narrow heel doesn't make them unstable. I will be wearing these to chapter every week from now on

I am obsessed, these are my favorite of the three and they weren't even what I set out to buy! Nine West "Goodnews"