Pardon the crash, as I'm not a Lambda Chi, nor do I know the person you're shopping for. However, as a graduating senior this semester, I'm definitely not looking for something like a lettered or screen printed shirt or sweatshirt. If you do go for a fraternity related gift I would try to go for something more subtle.
Some of the things on my Delta Chi wish list for graduation gifts are:
- Life Loyal Membership
- A windbreaker or fleece zip up with small letters embroidered on the left chest
- A framed picture of our spiritual founder, Sir Edward Coke
Some other things you might try: cuff links, if he'll wear them, a tie bar, a nice pen (but if you're going to get a nice pen a Mont Blanc is a much better gift than any fraternity pen you can find), golf accesories, if he plays, etc. Less collegiate frat boy, more professional fraternity man.