View Single Post
  #4  
Old 02-19-2010, 12:03 PM
Little32 Little32 is offline
GreekChat Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: At my new favorite writing spot.
Posts: 2,239
I have seen quite a few school-centric, fantasy novels published for adolescents, since HP. Growing up, I don't remember reading so many of those. I think Rowling actually heavily shaped the genre in that way.

To the accusations: one or two similarities, maybe. However, I think it is the amalgamation of all of those things together that would suggest plagiarism. Also, if there is a game like Quidditch in Willy the Wizard, Rowling has some explaining to do.

HP always seemed to lean a little heavily on LOTR to me, but that would be more of a "conventions of the genre" set of circumstances.

It would be great if this were all just a ploy to get HP readers to buy WW to "see for themselves" if there was plagiarism. That would be a gold mine.
__________________
You think you know. But you have no idea.
Reply With Quote