Okay, I've got two more big coincidences:
When I was in grammar school, I used to hang around with this one girl occasionally. We had our "own school bathroom" where we'd go & talk about everything. I had closer friends, but there was something about her; we seemed somehow alike. I was reading a copy of the Arrow, (our magazine) when I saw her name listed as a member of our Alpha chapter at Monmouth College. I was not surprized to find that we'd both become Pi Phis.
Also, while in college one of my Pi Phi roomates and I used to go to horse shows and horse barns together. Sixteen years later I was at a cat show and ran into her again - we were both showing cats this time, although different breeds. She was in my wedding two years later, thanks to this coincidental meeting.
Who else has coincidences, warm and fuzzy preferred? Or else just plain unusual ones?