Going back to the original concept - I don't care if it is a child of 5 or a high school senior of 18, an adult going through recruitment or a worker at his/her workplace - NO ONE would want to be put at the front of their class/group, discussed then voted on. Except maybe "Survivor" - but let's leave reality tv out of this.
Heck, can you imagine if we put pnms in the front of the group and then had everyone discuss them and vote then and there for membership selection?
What if they did it in your workplace?
It is a stupid, cruel idea.