Thread: Livid
View Single Post
  #29  
Old 03-04-2002, 03:54 PM
justamom justamom is offline
GreekChat Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 3,401
Two examples

2002 story
http://www.shreveporttimes.com/html/...86F51CE5.shtml
Jackson points to her prom at Mansfield High School as an example. She was prom queen her senior year. That prom was the first attempt in recent history to merge the black and white proms into one. Other years, they were held on separate nights.



1994
http://www.holysmoke.org/fem/fem0380.htm
For example, last spring a private high school in Chicago had two
proms -- one mainly attended by white students and the other mainly
attended by black students. The controversy arose when the
all-white prom committee was choosing songs. Each student could
vote for three songs, and the songs with the most votes would be
played at the prom. It turned out that many of the black student's
songs were not chosen.

The black students felt shut out by the decision-making process
based on majority rule. Guinier quoted one student as saying: "With
us being in the minority, we're always out-voted. It's as if we
don't count."

White students were hurt that their black peers were holding a
separate prom. They thought the black students were not playing by
the rules, namely the supposedly fair majority rule, Guinier said.

An alternative to the situation would be to give each student 10
votes to place on how ever many songs, reflecting the intensity of
their preferences. In this way, the black students could pool their
votes to hear some of their songs at the prom. So even if the
majority's favorite songs were played more often, the "songs that
the minority enjoyed would also show up on the roster."
Reply With Quote