Those padded bulletin boards with cross-hatched ribbons are always cute. Most Christmas fabric is on clearance now so perhaps you could find an inexpensive print that isn't too seasonal yet has your colors. Actually a red and cream toile with green ribbons or vice versa would be quite classic. I'm pretty sure I've seen squirrel buttons in JoAnn's in the woodland series but when I googled it, nothing popped up.
http://www.diynetwork.com/diy/ld_oth...269939,00.html