Adam,
I have to totally agree with Brother Jono. We do that at LX Z and I guarentee you that each New Brother will remember it for ever. I have mine from 1966 and have it framed. I also know while maybe not all of my Brothers still have it, most do just as Jono does!
I also have one when I was in the Ritual as the first candidate as an Alumni. They are both very important to me as all Brothers there signed it.
Spend the extra, it will be well worth it for all involved for years to come.
I know my name is on one from BN and Jono's is on one from LX.