How long is the dress? Knee-length, tea-length? If it's shorter, I'd go with the white strappy sandals with a wedge cork heel, to give you a little more height and show off calf muscles. Besides, the wedge heel is a little sturdier since you haven't been on heels in a while
With a longer dress, simple shoes are better. Maybe white or pale pink peep toes.
http://www.zappos.com/n/p/dp/28258672/c/107445.html
I'm not at all saying "Buy these!" because they're kind of pricey but I love looking for shoes on Zappos then buying them somewhere like Famous Footwear or Ross.
