Thread: American Idol 5
View Single Post
  #2  
Old 03-01-2006, 11:18 AM
irishpipes irishpipes is offline
GreekChat Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Reddest of the red
Posts: 4,509
Unimpressive overall. I could have a real hate-fest over Heather and Brenna. Both think they are great and neither is even average. Even the great ones weren't so hot tonight (Mandisa, Paris, Katherine.) I guess the judges heard something different with Kellie than I did. I thought it was a karaoke bar version of a great song, and her country-bumpkin shtick is annoying. Also, not one of the judges mentioned that Lisa Tucker was flat in several places. My cuts for the evening:
Heather for sure
Brenna for sure
Kellie
Melissa or Kinnik (actually I think both have good voices, but no crowd connection)
__________________
Adding 's does not make a word, not even an acronym, plural
Reply With Quote