Thanks all for your advice, keep it coming
I think i'm going to take the Jetta off my list. I've heard way too many bad things about it since i've started asking around.
ZTAngel- one of my good friends/recent roommate had the CRV. It was okay, but I wasn't a fan of it. I personally didn't like the way it handled.
I'm only considering the Santa Fe because I am sorta worried about driving in the winter b/c with my job I may have to drive a lot, to WV and such. But then it has kinda not so great gas mileage so i'm not sure.
I'm not sure if i'm an Outback sorta girl... not my style. I like the sporty imprezas, and my parents have had fabulous luck with their Subarus (2 Forresters and an older Impreza).
So I guess at the top of my list right now is the Tiburon and the RSX. I want to test drive stuff soon, but I also need to figure out what I can afford.
WVU Alpha Phi- I don't think Toyota's making Celicas this year... there's none on their website.