Maybe its b/c I am from Brooklyn where there is a good pizza place on every other corner but I can't believe people put places like Pizza Hut & Papa Johns on their lists.
L & B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn is simply the best. The Sicialian Slices are amazing! They also have great regular pizza, pasta & spumoni. I can't believe it didn't make your top 5 Russ! They have a website with pics if anyone wants to check it out:
L&B Spumoni Gardens