Quote:
Originally posted by Lindz928
Ok now, if Harry himself really WAS a horcrux, then WHY would Voldemort keep trying to kill him????? I don't see any way that this idea is true.... I think it's possible that Voldemort could be wanting to make the last Horcrux with Harry's death but that still seems pretty flimsy.
|
This is EXACTLY what I was going to say: WHY would Voldemort keep trying to kill Harry if he had put part of his soul into him? I could understand him holding out to use Harry's death to create the last horcrux, but I don't think the idea of Harry actually being a horcrux holds any water. (I've been wrong at times, but it's just what I think).
I dunno, I still am of the opinion that Snape is really evil. I've been rereading all the books, and although he makes a pretty good double agent I just get the feeling he is evil. JKR has done alll this work to try and redeem him in everyone's eyes at the end of each book, but is it just a trick? I was reading an interview with her and when someone mentioned the "redemptive pattern" Snape tends to have, she responded: "I promise you, whoever asked that question, can I just say to you that I’m slightly stunned that you’ve said that and you’ll find out why I’m so stunned if you read Book 7. That’s all I’m going to say."
It is difficult to discern if Dumbledore was pleading for Snape to save him or to kill him before he dies.
May I just say that I'm dying to read book 7 already?
