[MysticCat]

It's Friday morning and there isn't enough caffeine in the world. I'm surprised anyone can understand me this morning.

Yes, the two seals were different.

The "original" seal on his shingle was red; it looked much like the one shown in the picture I linked: three stars, clasped hands and the Greek letters of his chapter all in a triangle, surrounded by a circle that said (I think) "Davidson College, Phi Alpha of Beta Theta Pi."

The seal that he received on his Fraternal Fifty was gold with the Beta Coat-of-Arms in the center and "The Great Seal of Beta Theta Pi * 1839 *" in the surrounding circle.