Making the Band: 3
 

Lol...i think i'm going to like this season too, they have some really good singers too!!

I don't know if it is just me, but Aubrey looks OVERLY tanned. But this show is gonna be great.

So what do you all think of the new band?

My favorite was always Wanita and Dominique...so i'm glad to see at least one of them in the group, but other than that...BOO!! to diddy

Its not that I didn't like them....they just weren't my favorite.

If I had to choose between the two of them, I'd go with Aundrea, she's more like me. I knew Aubrey was gonna get in, that was an obvious choice.....i still think her and Diddy had something going on between them.


But like someone said in the other thread about MTB....he chose these girls based on their dancing, not their singing. If he had based it on singing, there would be no way he could justify not picking Dominique.

I DO NOT LIKE SHANNON!!!!! There was nothing speacial about her....she needs to be cut! lol

I made my fiance watch the finale with me and, except for Wanita, I nailed every girl Diddy picked in order. My fiance was like, "why are you wathcing if you knew what was going to happen?" hehe

I didn't like Dominique. She has a good voice, but she couldn't stick with the dancing to save her life. I don't think he picked the band just on dancing, because all the girls are strong singers but, if he wanted a complete package, it was obvious he wouldn't pick Dominique.

The one person I liked that didn't make the band was Jasmine. But, after her vocal/no harmony interview, I knew she wasn't going to cut it. I don't really have an opinion of Wanita because they rarely showed her.

I loved Dominique and was sad that she didn't get picked. But I have a feeling that she will get signed by Andre Harrell because he was her biggest fan. I am sooooooooooooo happy that he did not pick Denosh. She got on my nerves.

i just saw the re-run this am... i was so glad that aubrey and aundrea got in. i would have liked to have seen taquita make it. i just loved her!

Aubrey was a guarantee. For some reason I got the feeling that she was Diddy's secret favorite. I like her better with straight hair. None of this foofy shit, and she needs to get rid of that fake tan.

I was surprised Aundrea made it. I thought that Melissa would get picked for sure. I like Aundrea, but IMO she wasn't as strong as Melissa.

Not surprised Dominique did not make the band. Sure she can sing...but she was the token 'chunky girl' and she could not dance. Those faces she'd make while dancing were her nails on the coffin. But that girl can sing, so she'll definitely get picked up by somebody.

I knew Shannon would make the band way back from that episode where she and Kaui were dancing in front of Diddy and Diddy made that "since when do white girls dance like that?" comment. She was one of those who just chilled in the background, but when she was called up, she stepped up.

Overall, good picks. Good job, Diddy.

Random thought....what ever happened to Diddy's girl group Dream? If we wanted a girl group, he could have worked with the one he had.

Eh, they were too "pop girly". Bubble gum pop comes to mind -- and I think when they debuted, bubble gum pop was pretty much fizzing out. Plus they were all under the age of 18 at that time.

Granted, they had one good song, well two...but only one really picked up at mainstream. They were mediocre. I don't really see them at the same level with the girls from MTB3.

An article about Dream

So who all made it? I watched the first fifteen minutes then fell asleep. MTV's site isn't updated