DrPhil |
05-21-2011 01:43 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by PiKA2001
(Post 2057510)
Everyone from David Bowie to Madonna to Lady Gaga has altered or changed how they look in photo-shoots and music video's sooooo.... why can't Beyonce?
|
...why can't Beyonce what? She has changed her look a few times over the years. That isn't what this topic is about as far as I'm concerned.
David Bowie, Madonna, Lady Gaga, and Grace Jones have all changed their looks a few times to be more edgy and androgynous (gender). Bowie, Madonna, and Lady Gaga didn't stop looking immediately identifiable as white and Grace Jones didn't stop looking immediately identifiable as Black. In fact, racial and ethnic minority performers are more likely than white performers to become more racially unidentifiable.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MasTNX
(Post 2057499)
That's what I thought too. Which is an interesting comparison because my linesister and I have had many conversations about how artists like Shakira and Beyonce have dyed their hair blonde and made themselves more racially ambiguous seemingly to attract a larger audience.
I couldn't help but see the irony in the movie Dreamgirls as Jamie Foxx moved Beyonce to be the lead singer when he realized that her lighter skin and less soulful voice got a better reaction from white audiences. It reminded me a lot of Destiny Child's journey.
|
I agree.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MasTNX
(Post 2057499)
But who knows, it may just be the lighting of photo shoot and some photographer's artistic vision.
|
;) You say all of that and end with "who knows...may just be the lighting...." That's how these dynamics persist in entertainment and other institutions. We can't prove it in most cases and there's just enough uncertainty to make people conclude with "who knows...I guess I'll move on."
Quote:
Originally Posted by christiangirl
(Post 2057470)
I'm tempted to throw in a "Ditto" hear because this was my first thought. "She's just super washed out from the lighting." But it's a professional photo. They know how to not do that, but they did. Maybe a clever way of intentionally lightening her without looking blatantly intentional. Eh Phil?
|
It looks like a photo shoot with the bright lights. Even attempting a "photo shoot look" has the outcome of making some people wonder who she is and "what" she is. Surface-level racial and ethnic neutrality and comfort accomplished.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xidelt
(Post 2057420)
The first thought that popped into my head when I saw the cover was "Is that Shakira?"
|
That's arguably what the duet they did together was expected to accomplish. They look alike and both of them are "racial and ethnic minority enough" to be "racial and ethnic minority" and "neutral enough" to be "neutral."
|