Ben and Jerry's - Bringing Back Flavors
 

Vote to renew a retired Ben and Jerry's Flavor!

My favorite was Wavy Gravy! That stuff was hella good!

aaww man, whatever happened to peanut turtles?

White Russians are retired? I could have sworn that I had one of those in Chapel Hill a few months ago.

i'm all about anything with peanut butter in it!

- marissa

I didn't think they made Ben & Jerry's anymore, period. Do they? You've given me hope! :)

Of course they still make Ben & Jerry's!!!!

I have trouble finding it around here. Guess I'm just not looking in the right spot. *sigh* Now at least I don't have to cry every time I wear my tie-dye "Cherry Garcia" t-shirt. :p

strange. everywhere around here sells it plus we have ben & jerry's ice cream stores here too. maybe it's a new england thing?

I think it is a New England thing. I've been in every other part of the country, and haven't seen it represented nearly as much as it is here.

I wish Baskin and Robbins (what few stores they have left) would bring back English Toffee. :(

It seems like a few more have sprung up around here in New England when paired with Dunkin Donuts. I don't see too many starting up on their own, though.

I remember a B & J flavor... I think it was Oatmeal Cookie. I never see it anywhere though. But I didn't see it on the list either.

But I'm down for anything with PB and Chocolate in it.

Cool Britannia

The summer I worked at a bible camp this was the desert of choice for the staff. The mini deep freeze in the staff HQ cabin was filled with only this ice cream for 3 months. Anytime you needed a break from the kids, just plop down in a couch in the HQ cabin and have some ice cream.

I also voted for Cool Britannia:D

As I am well versed in Ben and Jerry's ( I worked there for 7 years) I can tell you we lost our fair share of kick ass flavors to non popularity with the mass market. One of my many favorites was Chocolate Raspberry Swirl.

And incidentally Jill, there were 2 different formulations of Wavy Gravy. The original was way sweeter than the 2nd, it was a caramel brazilnut ice cream with caramel swirls and chocolate covered toffee chunks. The 2nd (and my preferred wavy) had chocolate hazelnut swirl.
Ahh...the good old days.:)

Oh, how I miss Fresh Georgia Peach.

I was rather fond of Southern Pecan Pie. Now, I'll settle for Uncanny Cashew.

Apple Crumble
 

was the best non-chocolate flavor EVAR!!!

and I don't see it mentioned. :(

It's worth every penny. Seriously, life is too short to eat cheap ice cream.

Wiser words were never written.

Why pay $2 for crappy ice cream when you can pay $4 for amazing ice cream?

You all suck. You just made me go buy some chunky monkey.


(only in this thread can I say that and make sense, lmao)

Don't feel bad, I'm going to the grocery in a bit and I'll be coming home with Phish Food.

You can't vote to bring back s'mores which i LOVED... but I do enjoy the half baked flavor

I miss Concession Obsession... best ice cream EVER. Sno-Capps, chocolate covered peanuts, nestle crunch, caramel, etc....

World's Best Vanilla was my favorite. It was the only one I would eat, since I hate crunchy stuff in ice cream. The vanilla for a change wasn't near as good.

vote link
 

mmm, half baked
 

Free coupon when you vote? Sweet!

My favorite: Oatmeal Cookie Chunk or Heath Bar Crunch. Mmmmmmmmmmmm!!!!!!!!!!

Southern Pecan Pie. That was the best ice cream I have ever bought from a store. Those big chunks of crust would make you slap somebody! I am soooooo mad they don't make that anymore.:mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad: :mad:

Oh. . . my. . . goodness. . . you are soooo right! Those big, gargantuan chunks of heath bar in there - no other heath crunch ice cream can compare.

Okay, I think I'll go get some tomorrow. This is actually the only ice cream from B & J's that I eat. Breyer's is the only Butter Pecan that I eat.

I think maybe its a major city thing ? They carry it in supermarkets here in Cali, and we have three B&J ice cream stores just in like a 1/2 mile of my place. I don't know if they stopped making it but I LOVE One sweet Whirld... it has Marshmallow creme in it YUMMY !!

It isn't retired, but B & J's Chocolate Therapy is the most delicious ice cream evah - a combination of chocolate ice cream, chocolate pudding, and chocolate cookies. You should try it today.