Lindsay Lohan or Hillary Duff?
 

You decide.

http://thejournalnews.com/mtvgallery/images/21.jpg

http://entimg.msn.com/i/150/ce/may/l...an_150x207.jpg

Lindsay's definitely prettier (how jealous am i of that little 18 year old??), but I have to stick with Hilary....my idol haha

They are both cute. Lindsay looks like my sister did when she was a teenager. I first noticed the resemblance while watching "Freaky Friday" which was a fun movie.

I'm not jealous of their looks. I'm jealous that these girls will make more money before they turn 21 than I will earn in my entire life. I should breed and have a future teen queen movie star. :p

Lindsay is hotter.

Lohan has less of the "I'm 14" thing going on.

So her.

Lindsey also has less Disney drama, and (I believe) more talent.

I like Hilary overall. She seems like a sweet girl. I think Lindsay is a good actress and I like her movies. But something about that girl irks me.

It's all about Lindsay.

I watched Freaky Friday last night.

Hootie McBoob errrrr Lindsay Lohan

Lindsay. We were born on the same day! :)

Lindsay Lohan, absolutely

Lohan by far.

Hillary Duff!!!

I have an enormous girl-crush on Lindsay Lohan.

ME TOO.

Lindsay! I don't get the Hillary hype.

Hillary. Arya, remember what I said about the snow. I need to ask about Hill but I don't think she likes winter much.

-Rudey

Lindsay. Definitely.

Re: Lindsay Lohan or Hillary Duff?
 

Hilary Duff. :)

Lohan ALL THE WAY!!!

Lindsay has an excellent nose

http://www.physics.ohio-state.edu/~s...lindsay-tn.jpg


Hilary; not bad but not as good as Lindasy

http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/mo/lionking4.jpg


So I have to say Lindsay.

She looks even more like my sister in this picture. It's freaking me out.

We have extremely cute noses in my family. You would like us, KillarneyRose. :)

Do people feel that certain girls are more attractive when they're younger?

I just see Lindsay as having this rounder look and while she's hot, I think she won't be a hottie in 5 years.

And I really don't understand your nose thing. I thought Duff's nose was cuter but I'm no nose expert so I guess I'll have to accept your nose diagnosis.

-Rudey

Lindsay!

Hilary comes off as one of those pretty, snotty, cliquey, bitchy girls that I would have come to blows with in middle school.

Lindsay seems like the type that would have sat back and made fun of them with me.

Hilary seems too full of herself. Lindsay seems more laid back and real.

Hilary has one way of delivering lines. It sucks IMO. Lindsay can actually act.

lindsay totally.

hillary duff is annoying and now her sister is attempting to get into the act. blah. plus i don't like the resemblance between her and (how eloquently munchkin put it) twatney (LOL).....her cd cover requires a double take. ick. :p

i think lindsay has a cool speaking voice....kinda raspy. she just seems like a cool laid back kinda chick. hillary=high maintenance.

LOL, I think you are right about Hill no liking winter. BTW, did the pictures of Lindsay came out right?

Lindsay Lohan!...I've loved her in the Parent Trap wayyy back when and then also in Mean Girls! :D

LOL I showed them to EVERYONE. That's why I created a whole thread praising you in Chit Chat before the vacation. AWESOME.

-Rudey

I liked Hilary Duff when it was just her on Lizzie McGuire. Since she's become more famous (and as Lindsay Lohan has too) I've liked her less. She's become sort of annoying to me. If we want to talk about who's hotter, right now I'd say Lindsay because Hilary still has a little girl look about her, which makes sense because she is the younger one.

Lindsay... I like redheads

Now see, it's the opposite for me! Lindsay is the mean one whereas Hilary is just a kid...harmless.

But Hilary's acting is atrocious!

Oh - I don't know! They're both babies so I shouldn't even been saying negative things! Ok - love 'em both just the same!!

I think Hilary is better and so does my guy friends too!!!

Lohan, bigger boobs...heard she gives anal

Hillary Duff is much hotter!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EWWW. wtf.

anyway, my vote goes to Lindsay, shes def. a better actress more versitel with more talent and everything. i dont like however how both hilary and now lindsay are trying to do the whole singing career....hella annoying!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

to me hilary seems more fake. i mean all she did was the lizzie mcguire role and thats it.

I bet Lindsey Lohan's father could kick Hillary Duff's father's a$$. After all, he got arrested for beating up one of his brothers.

i think Hillary is fun. My love for her acting stopped at "Lizzie McGuire". I kinda want her album though.

Anywho, I pick Lindsay. She seems cooler. I love her movies and I think that she has a good singing voice. I am interested in hearing her upcoming album.

It sounds like she definitely comes from an interesting family. That might be part of her edge and what makes her come across as a pretty down girl. Hillary seems a little more giggly and girly.

Hillary Duff, hands down.

Lindsay Lohan....if I were 16 I'd probably want to be her. Except the black version. :rolleyes: :D :p