Here's hoping the girls put up better performances than the guys did.

so far..hopes dashed..

Sigh.

You would think none of them had ever seen the show before and had never heard the concept of "song choice" or do something besides standing there like a stiff.

Even Paula is disapointing... not near as drunk/high as she was last night so her comments are actually relevant and logical. Give me Drunk Paula... much more entertainment value on a night when the contestants are snoozers.

this is really pathetic
 

since some of these chicks have other professional experiences, their performances should have been tighter.

This season is soooooooooooo boring.

things are starting to pick up... (slightly)

and I agree.. the performances should be tight...

Syesha needed the anchor spot tonight instead of Carly

yeah, I wasn't getting the whole Carly thing at all...

Sigh, another snoozefest. I only liked Alaina, Ramiele, and Syesha.

Why is it that some of these contestants are amazing during auditions and Hollywood but then can't sing a decent note once they make the top 24?!? So disappointing.

You would think they only gave them a very small group of songs to choose from... WHY out of the American Idol clearanced catalog would they pick those songs from the 60s?

Oh, and Randy-- Connie Francis is the one we remember for singing "Where the Boys Are."

THANK YOU!!! I said the exact same thing to my husband. And then he was giving Simon crap later about being in the music business and not knowing a song!!

I've gotta give Paula Abdul credit -- ol' girl looked GOOD in her video!

I recently saw a preview of Janet Jackson's new video, she looks really good too.

Go late 80s/early 90s icons!

Yay, "America got it right" tonight! The 4 that should have been voted off were!

Yeah, but it's still dull. Maybe I've seen too much AI over the years.

Completely agree. I still don't get how the Leif Garrett kid made it on.