GreekChat.com Forums

GreekChat.com Forums (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/index.php)
-   Sorority Recruitment (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/forumdisplay.php?f=217)
-   -   2007 UGA Recruitment (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/showthread.php?t=89398)

KSUViolet06 08-14-2007 06:30 PM

This story reminds me of something that happened at my school.

Last fall, there was a chapter that had been placed on some sort of probation by their HQ. As part of their probation, they weren't allowed to have social events (date party, formal, etc) and they were not permitted to participate in Homecoming activities for one year.

Panhellenic was aware of this, but didn't feel that it was their responsibility to let PNMs know that XYZ was on probation and what that meant. It was announced at PHC meetings that there would be no mention of XYZ's probation at Recruitment Orientation and that other sororities were not to comment on it if a PNM asked about it during a party.

Panhellenic basically left it up to XYZ to let the PNMs know about it. Of course no sorority wants to tell PNMs "you should join us, but we can't do anything fun until next year." So they decided it would be best not to mention it during recruitment.

So girls went through recruitment knowing nothing about it. If they heard "tent talk" about it, they asked their Rho Chi, who told them they knew nothing about it. So the PNMs either figured it was a rumor or that it was no big deal.

XYZ pledged quota of new members on Bid Day. Then of course since they were new members, they started to learn more about the chapter and heard rumblings about probation and not having socials. So they were curious and started asking about it.

A few weeks after Bid Day, the XYZ new member educator sat the new girls down and told them about the probation situation. They were really upset because they felt totally lied to. HALF of their new member class depledged and most of them ended up joining other sororities the next year.

So I guess that's a story about how NOT to handle probation issues during recruitment. I'd rather see a chapter be honest during recruitment and have some girls cut them, than not mention it, pledge quota, and then have girls depledge because they were lied to.

UGAalum94 08-14-2007 06:55 PM

I think honesty is the best policy. You'd like to think you had something to offer other than one year of parties.

It kind of makes you wonder how the IHQs weigh it all out when they dole out penalties.

violet14 08-14-2007 06:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cluelessUGAmom (Post 1502306)
I of course called my friend and told her about the recs yesterday and that they were important. She said when she called Arizona they laughed at her and said their rush is not at all like the "South" -- it is much more laid back so she was assured she did not need the recs. I sure hope she does not encounter anything different when she arrives as that would be disappointing! Had the same conversation with my friend whose D is going to Penn State too!

I am concerned about the impression that your friend may have about not needing a rec because she is going through rush at a non-SEC school. I personally went to a non-SEC school and am now an advisor for an SEC school so I know both ends of the spectrum. My insight on a non-SEC rush is that while it is not as necessary to have a rec and will not necessarily hurt your chances of recieving a bid it does GREATLY improve your chances. Most sororities at non-SEC schools tend to be smaller chapters and have smaller numbers going through recruitment, because of this they operate a little differently. Many of these chapters have rules such as if a girl has a rec then she cannot be dropped before a certain time. This gives your friend the advantage of having more time with the sorority to see if there is a connection. My neice is about to go through rush at a college in Arizona and because my sorority is not going to consider her a legacy I called the advisor of my chapter to find out exactly what their guidelines were and I was told that because recs were not as common at this school being as it is non-SEC that when girls have recs they have much higher success and usually whoever writes the rec will recieve a call from the chapter if the girl is being dropped. Now understanding that this simply the procedure for one group I cannot speak for the others but know that the greek life office may say it's not necessary because it won't matter in the end (which is might not) it can't hurt and can only improve her chances. I hope that this insight helps a little if you talk to your friend again before her recruitment begins. Best Wishes.

kathyc 08-14-2007 09:05 PM

MamaDawg and UGA Dad,
We are all thinking of you tonight as your baby dawgs wait for their pref parties. I hope both girl are invited back to the house they want most. And Mama Dawg, I've got both fingers crossed and a red carnation on my pillow.

UGAalum94 08-14-2007 10:15 PM

Are the Rho Chis (or whatever they are called these days) really pushing COB as an option for girls who don't like their results? (or talking it up more than usual?)

I keep kind of hearing it in the context of girls dropping out, but it doesn't make much sense to drop with hopes of COB if you still have the groups who usually COB on your party list.

And at UGA COB isn't likely to involve that many groups most years. Snap bids, maybe, but COB, not so much or at least any kind of open COB that PNMs are likely to know about.

UGADad 08-14-2007 10:30 PM

Brumby
 
On top of everything else, there was a fire alarm in Brumby tonight -- somebody burned some bagels. So these tired girls, especially the ones on the top floors, had to walk down all those stairs and stand outside for most of an hour.

As for the tent talk -- who can blame the pnms? Especially the ones with no prior knowledge of reputations and few friends or even acquuaintances among the actives. They have had a grand total of 70 minutes with each of the sororities that are still alive for them. They are starving for information. They think they know who they like, but how can they be even remotely confident that they have a true sense of what each sorority is really like?

UGAalum94 08-14-2007 10:38 PM

The only real problem with tent talk is that the PNMs don't just get talked into one group instead of another, sometimes they get talked out of groups that otherwise they might have liked. And often times the information isn't actually true.

For instance, at some campuses, although not UGA that I know of, some groups are plagued by persistent tent talk that they are in danger of closing when they aren't, and this year at UGA, a group may or may not be on social probation. If they are, it's good for the PNMs to know it, if if they aren't, some PNM may shy away from a great experience for bad reasons.

While wanting to know all you can is understandable, it's not really helpful if you are using bad information to make your decisions.

cluelessUGAmom 08-14-2007 10:57 PM

telephone game
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by UGADad (Post 1502485)
On top of everything else, there was a fire alarm in Brumby tonight -- somebody burned some bagels. So these tired girls, especially the ones on the top floors, had to walk down all those stairs and stand outside for most of an hour.

As for the tent talk -- who can blame the pnms? Especially the ones with no prior knowledge of reputations and few friends or even acquuaintances among the actives. They have had a grand total of 70 minutes with each of the sororities that are still alive for them. They are starving for information. They think they know who they like, but how can they be even remotely confident that they have a true sense of what each sorority is really like?

UGADad,

I just got off the phone with my daughter and she told me about the fire as well. I'm laughing because she told me that someone burnt popcorn in a microwave and they had to check every room!!!!!!!! So bagels, popcorn mmm.... why would they have to check every room if the person who burnt whatever knew "where" they burnt it!!!!!

As for the Red and Black link -- I was not nearly as upset with the article as I was with the posts. I was very shocked to read what I read in regard to all the slander of the greeks and specifically the sorority identified. But what was really sad was what some of the responses from the girls were! If I was a recruit I would certainly take that into consideration as representation of some in that house.

Looking forward to posts in the morning after the schedules are out. At least they don't have to be there until 7:40 tomorrow!

UGADad 08-14-2007 10:58 PM

I agree with you (AlphaGamUGAAlum). I'm not saying it is right or good, just unavoidable and understandable.

By the way, UGADaughter asked her recruitment adviser tonight about the sanctions for the sorority on "social probation", and one of her friends separately asked her adviser. The answer was identical - the only sanction for this probation is that there can be no alcohol out during social functions. Of course, some of us think that should be the rule anyway -- these girls are 17 and 18 afterall!

Anyway, no restrictions on number of recruits, and no restriction on the ability to have social events. At least that is the word from the Rho Chis (I hope that's the right name).

UGADad 08-14-2007 11:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cluelessUGAmom (Post 1502502)
UGADad,

I just got off the phone with my daughter and she told me about the fire as well. I'm laughing because she told me that someone burnt popcorn in a microwave and they had to check every room!!!!!!!! So bagels, popcorn mmm.... why would they have to check every room if the person who burnt whatever knew "where" they burnt it!!!!!

As for the Red and Black link -- I was not nearly as upset with the article as I was with the posts. I was very shocked to read what I read in regard to all the slander of the greeks and specifically the sorority identified. But what was really sad was what some of the responses from the girls were! If I was a recruit I would certainly take that into consideration as representation of some in that house.

Looking forward to posts in the morning after the schedules are out. At least they don't have to be there until 7:40 tomorrow!

That's really funny about the different fire stories.

Where did you find the posts with responses from the girls? I'd like to read those. I just think we need to be careful jumping to conclusions about a group of 200 girls for what could have been the actions of just a very few. And unfortunately, as college kids go these days, I suspect you could fine a few who might do thi kind of thing in almost every group of 200.

cluelessUGAmom 08-14-2007 11:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UGADad (Post 1502507)
That's really funny about the different fire stories.

Where did you find the posts with responses from the girls? I'd like to read those. I just think we need to be careful jumping to conclusions about a group of 200 girls for what could have been the actions of just a very few. And unfortunately, as college kids go these days, I suspect you could fine a few who might do thi kind of thing in almost every group of 200.

I couldn't agree more. But still, those "few" were chosen/selected to "fit in" to that house. Sometimes there is truth to some accusations about reputations - in both good and bad ways. But, just as the posts mentioned about the chapter that shut down being predominantly Jewish - this may or may not be true but that was the perception and as adults in the real world and workplace we know that too often, "perception = reality" no matter how unfair or biased it is.

ok I'm starting to ramble and need to go to bed! But to answer your question, the posts are in a link just under the article. there were about 70 or so posts.

UGADad 08-15-2007 09:26 AM

Day 5
 
Well it is underway, and we can all take a breath (yes AJC you can quote me on that:D).

Best wishes to all the young ladies and their families today. I hope there is much happiness and very little heartbreak.

Hopefully the freshmen girls can find time today to venture onto campus and find the buildings where they will actually begin CLASSES tomorrow!

cluelessUGAmom 08-15-2007 09:29 AM

I'll be able to sleep tonight!
 
Well, with only the 1 rec phoned in, my D has a full sked today with her top 2 on it!!!! #3 has all along not been one of her "fits" but she kept saying they seem to really like her. however, she is going to all 3 but she is considering not listing the #3 on her ranking - just the other 2 where she will be happy at either one. Is this the "suicide" thing?

But after reading about Auburn Mom who's D had full skeds every day and wound up with the bid of the one she didn't feel fit, and is still miserable, I'm thinking that my D should not list it if she does not want to be there at all. Any thoughts?

She told me too that she feels so badly for girls who didn't get any and also only got 1 or 2 that they didn't really like. She told me about 1 girl who got 3 and complained that she didn't really like any of them and I advised her that the girl may be feeling that way because she didn't get her top choice and she needs to make the best of today and be glad she has 3! My D also tried to be very quiet when she got her sked and didn't say anything unless she was asked because she saw some girls get so excited and they were right next to others who didn't get 1 -- this is really tough.

Apparently there are 4 rounds today - but still they only go to 3; it is just that one house wanted smaller groups or is a small house and needed more time or something like that.

AlphaFrog 08-15-2007 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cluelessUGAmom (Post 1502634)
Well, with only the 1 rec phoned in, my D has a full sked today with her top 2 on it!!!! #3 has all along not been one of her "fits" but she kept saying they seem to really like her. however, she is going to all 3 but she is considering not listing the #3 on her ranking - just the other 2 where she will be happy at either one. Is this the "suicide" thing?

Putting 2/3 is not considered "maximizing your options" and would make her ineligible for snap bids and Quota Additions (they're confusing, there are whole threads on them, but basically, it means that she can get a bid outside of the normal quota restrictions...).

I've suggested this before, but you need to have her check with her local PHC before doing so, to make sure they don't count this as not maximizing...She could put the two that she liked, and then one that cut her first round.
So, say she really liked ABC and XYZ, and also liked GBH, but GBH cut her first round, her bid card could read:
1.XYZ
2.ABC
3.GHB
Since she most likely wouldn't appear anywhere on their bidlist, she most likely wouldn't get a bid from them, but she would still be listing the maximum amount of groups.
Additionally, I wouldn't have her ask her Rho Gamma this (they probably wouldn't have a definitive answer)- I would have her ask either the Greek Life director or the PHC VP of Recruitment.

violet14 08-15-2007 09:58 AM

Partial Suicide
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cluelessUGAmom (Post 1502634)
Well, with only the 1 rec phoned in, my D has a full sked today with her top 2 on it!!!! #3 has all along not been one of her "fits" but she kept saying they seem to really like her. however, she is going to all 3 but she is considering not listing the #3 on her ranking - just the other 2 where she will be happy at either one. Is this the "suicide" thing?


The "suicide" thing is usually when a girl only lists one sorority after preference party. My chapter considered this a "partial suicide" and while I normally don't support suiciding because it can greatly hurt your chances of getting any bids I think that if your D is not comfortable with the 3rd house then she should not list it at all. Realistically - it is a possibility that your D is not high enough on the 2 favorites bid list to make a bid match so if she can't see herself in that 3rd choice then she doesn't need to list it at all. She just needs to make sure that she feels that strongly about this house because it does lessen her chances of a bid and at a school like UGA the COB process is sometimes non-existant (especially at the stronger sororities) because houses are already at total. I wish your D the best of luck - I am sure that she will make the decision that is best for her. Best of luck for both of your nerves as you wait for tomorrow.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.