Why, why, why was Carmen NOT in the bottom three? I am too through that Rickey was voted off. While I don't think he gave the best performance, it was better than Carmen's.

BTW, I LOVED RUUUBEN in his Ford commercial. If they could edit out Carmen, it would be even better.

Gina-you took the words right out of my mouth!

I don't know HOW that girl keeps slipping through. No big fan of Rickey but he did not deserve to get booted this week.

Now- is it just me but what did you think of Kelly Clarkson- the song grew on me (I watched the tape again) but the outfit did nothing for her-made her butt look big (and not in a flattering way). Comments??

I didn't like any of it--the song, the styling, the dancing. The song was written by Cristina Aguliera but it did not seem to fit in with Kelly at all.

I also can't believe that the movie "From Kelly to Justin" is coming out in movie theaters. It looks like it should be shown on regular TV as a made-for-tv movie. It would save a lot of money and embarassment.

I agree or been an after school special. I mean really how many fans does Kelly and Justin have? Would they have done this if it had been Tamyra as THE AMERICAN IDOL?!!?!??!!!??!

Now CT4, you KNOW the answer to this question!;)

How did Kim L. wind up in the bottom three, again????:mad: :mad: Rickey voted off - it should have been Carmen's raggedy behind packing her bags. :mad:

A.I. kicks rocks!!!!

I do't really wactch American Idol, but I thought it was wack that Rickey got voted off. That other girl should have definitely got booted!

While I think both Kimberly C. and Carmen are horrible, I was SO pleased to see Rickey go. He rubbed me wrong from the beginning. What's up with him looking like a 45 year old man? Then he started in with that "Hercules, Hercules" mess. And to top it off, his voice was mediocre at best. Also, I feel like everybody that I really like is safe now because if there's any justice in America, Kimberly C. and Carmen have the next two "buh-bye" slots on lock. I really wish Josh wasn't a Marine because he'd have been gone a long time ago.

BOOOOOOOOO that Rickey got told to kick rocks!!!!! Carmen sounded a hot mess and she got to stay???!!! I did not like that one little bit!! :mad: Believe me, she will kick rocks next week!!

And that little Kelly interlude in the show: I definitely was NOT feeling her new look or that song. That outfit did kinda make her backside look big.

As for that Justin/Kelly movie clip, it looked like a hot mess to me! Why are they asking people to spend $7.50-$8.00 (or whatever the movies cost nowadays) to see something that should have come directly to cable on USA or FX or something?? :confused: My hubby saw the clip too and said that it looked like it should have been called "Grease '03".

Don't ya'll just wanna run up and hug Ruben??? :D

I'm all for Ruben!!!! Carmen should have definitely got the boot. I expected her to be kicked off last week.

Since I am from Cleveland I am feeling you on the 93 Celebration tip I am so glad they don't play that song any more!!!!!!!

I agree with everyone.. carmen should have been gone. And I think that if the vote would have happen last week she would have been gone. But ruban is great. At this point even if something happens and he doesn't take idol.. he will have a contract. It was nice to see him in something other than the 205 jersey :) I will miss ricki this week. He is the only one really playing with the themes.. like the afro

I love Rueben and Clay. Clay lacks the personality that Rueben has though.

I hated those 205 shirts. I was so glad he took it off! Give me something different Rueben baby!


But I have to say I was crying with laughter with Rueben's little song montage. That tux looked too little and Carmen(I think that's her) when she was dancing with him was leaning on his belly. comedy!



QTE

From Us magazine:
 

Former American Idol finalist Vanessa Olivarez, 21, will appear nude in PETA's "I'd Rather Go Naked Than Wear Fur" ad campaign.

How bout I seen Corey Clark in the club last night in Nashville. I think he is from around here or something. He was walking around like he is the "American Idol" or something. He actually looked a hot mess to me and looks like someone that would resist arrest and beat up his little sisters.

IF anyone hears the kelly cd..Please post what you think of the Tamyra and Kelly duet

There's an article in the most recent issue of People about Corey and his family. His sory is that he thought the charges had been dropped, so technically it was like he was never arrested (or something like that). His mother says it was a typical brother sister fight--they were screaming at each other and stuff, one of them when out side and the other followed, continuting to yell, etc. The neighbor called the police. Corey still contends that he did not resist arrest.

Corey also said that the AI folks kinda set him up. One producer told him not to say anything and about the incident and that is why he "lied". He also said his little interview shown after he was kicked off was improperly edited.

Hmmmmm, I didnt know that.

smokey robinson looks a _____________ MESS!!!

WHAT THE HEAZY DOES CARMEN HAVE ON?

I Love Simon!!!!!!!!!!

my friend on a list said, " can carmen give the dress back to the mexican whore she stole it from"

LMBO!!!!!!!!!!

I was thinking "Why did she steal her grandma's underslip and dye it green?!"

~~~edited to add~~~
I just think Clay is the OOOGLIEST thing! I can't put my finger on it! :confused:

ROFL!!! :D :D :D

OMG, Kim L. looked so good tonight, and she sounded awesome.

Kim C., Carmen, and Josh should have their tracheas removed and used for research. They are all so, so horrible.

Trenyce is my GIRL, (but I think she got her dress from the mexican whore's friend) and she did have the cliched pitch problems, but STILL tight.

TOP: KIM L., RUBEN, TRENYCE

BOTTOM: CARMEN (sounds like an endangered species being poached), KIM C., JOSH (or GRIMACE from Sesame St.)

I'm hoping the war is over before this ends, so patriotism won't keep him on much longer. He can not sing!!!!! Even when they had the stupid country/rock category, he was all off key. And is it me, or is he overweight, with his tight a$$ slacks wearing self. He does not look cut, he looks chubby.

In the immortal words of Ideal08, OH THE HILARITY!!!!!!

YES LAWD!!! His eyes were scaring me! Like he was a demon or something! And his hair? I'm not even going to go there...

:D :D :D CTFU CTFU CTFU, chal you a mess.......LOL LOL

Did anyone else notice that when Ruben was telling why he picked his particular song that he had on one of those Jacob & Co. watches, either that or a GOOD knockoff? The one that tells time in 5 different time zones? Maybe his girl Trenyce hooked him up. :o ;)

Also Smokey looked a HOT mess! :mad: His hair reminded me of Rick James' current hairstyle.

you have got to be CRAPPIN me!!!!!

CARMEN beat KIMBERLY CALDWELL!! :confused: :mad:

YAAAAAAAAYYYYYYY!!!!! KICK ROCKS to Kimberley C.!!!! It wasn't Carmen but you know, I take what I can get. :D

I am so sick of Joshua!! He so needs to go!!!! All I can say is that patriotism is a good PR tool.

Next week's bottom 3 (or 2 since there's 6 left): Trenyce and Carmen, maybe Josh should the war come to an official end.

I would looove to see Carmen get told to kick rocks next week!! She has been on too long!!! Go back to high school or something, just go home!!!!

Next week I am casting at least 50 votes for Trenyce on GP. . . because the bottom 3 will now be TRENYCE, CARMEN and JOSH or Kim L.

For real man, if Kim L. goes before Josh or Carmen I am going to throw a fit. Even Simon acknowledges that the competition is basically between Kim and Ruben. Clay is good but BORING.

Carmen has some kind of dark powers. A mysterious force is at work.

CT4, I am with you on calling for Trenyce and Kim L. They are going to need all our votes now.

Josh, be gone! Carmen be gone!

HIP HIP HOORAY!!!
 

ONE BAD BLONDE IS GONE TODAY!!!

http://www.click-smilies.de/sammlung...smiley-047.gif

Next week I HOPE and PRAY that Carmen 15 minutes is up!!

I was so happy that for once Kim L. was NOT in the final 3.

And not to be un-patriotic but am I the only one that is not feeling "Proud to be an American"?

The first two times were cool but now it's starting to get on my nerves.

Don't forget! Idol is on three times next week. I am glad that Kim C is gone. Carmen and Josh have got to go. Well Ruben broke out the camoflage(sp) 205 jersey. lol I am wondering if he is going to take simons advice and change his style. I think he is doing just find. He knows his voice.

Re: HIP HIP HOORAY!!!
 

Girl you are not the only one...actually I think it sounded awful tonight! Somebody was sooooooooo off the entire time, I think it was Josh (trying to sing in that falsetto). Anywho...I am glad, hopefully Carmen will get booted next week.

I can't believe Kim Caldwell got booted before Carmen. She is just AWFUL!

Also, I agree with Simon, Ruben needs to change it up a bit. I'm getting kind of bored with his ballads. I think Kim L will give Ruben and Clay a run for their money (if she can stay out of the bottom 3.:mad: )

Re: Re: HIP HIP HOORAY!!!
 

I heard that too! I thought it might have been Carmen doing the falsetto though. I dunno I was trying to figure it out, cause the same voice was off during the first group sing.

I'm still in shock that Carmen lived to see another week :confused: :eek: :mad: :mad: :mad: .....

If Ryan would stop beggin for votes for that dang on Carmen she would have been off the show. I think people are giving her votes just because she always looks like she is going to cry when the judges tell her like it is!