I just thought he looked like a girl.

Whole bunch of "meh" tonight. I liked Blake and Chris S. and thought Brandon and Chris R. were OK. Really, it was very underwhelming tonight. I thought the guys were supposed to step it up each week!

Sanjaya looked like his sister tonight.

Phil was horrible.

I'm still not impressed with the guys. No one stood out this week.

I'm impressed with Blake's music choices. Jamiroquai and 311? Awesome! I couldn't believe none of the judges tonight could recognize that 311 song...it was quite popular when I was in college years ago.

The boys kinda sucked last night. I only really liked Chris S. and Jared.

Blake gets points for his interesting song choices, but I wish they had sped up the music a little...it seemed very slow.

I wish Sanjaya would just go home. He's a terrible singer, and everytime he opens his mouth it makes me want to scream.

Is it just me, or does he look like a woman?!?

Well last night blew.

I think I'll cry if Sanjaya makes it into the Top 12. I just can't see the producers allowing him to make it far enough that he'll go on the AI tour. He's truly awful.

Agreed. It's good to hear songs that haven't been done zillions of times already.

Snore. Wait, wake up and half like Chris S.

Brandon sounded good for once but not sure it will save him.

I wish Jared and Sanjaya would go.
I think Jared and Brandon will.

dialidol is really close this week, so it should be interesting...

My prediction for the final 3: Stephanie, Lakisha and Melinda.

Close...Lakisha, Melinda, and Chris S. ;)

Dear Sanjaya,

Just because you lived in Lihu`e for 4 years DOES NOT MEAN you know how to dance the hula. Hula =/= "shaking your booty Hawaiian style," you dipshit.

Your limpette self reminds me of the drag queen that used to frequent Hamburger Mary's back in the day.

Now, now. You don't like snarky remarks on people, remember? Can't have it both ways. You snark or you get snarked. Pick one.

Oh, I was SO waiting on your commentary of his Hula "skills" :rolleyes:. He really needs to dig a huge hole & just crawl into it... and please take Sundance with him... and most of the other guys too...

Antonella makes my ears bleed. GO HOME!

COSIGN!
Even the clip they showed of her at the, which usually features the good part of the song, was AWFUL!

I wish the dialidol predictions weren't so close this week! I can't figure out who's going to go home!

I never thought I'd see the day when a Pearl Jam song was done on AI. And Sundance sang it horribly. He sang it about a key higher than Eddie Vedder and with a vibrato. Not good at all.

Please go home: Antonella, Sanjaya, Haley and Sundance. The Dial Idol results don't look good for Stephanie. I will be really upset if Antonella stays and Stephanie goes. Who keeps voting for Antonella and Sanjaya?????

For Antonella, I think it's boys who want to continue seeing pictures. For Sanjaya... it has to be his momma. Because no one else in the world could POSSIBLY want to hear him sing anymore. Although I think he's sweet.

Am I the only one who says a silent prayer, every time I see or hear anything about Antonella that says "Dear Jesus, please don't let her be Greek." ??? lol :D

I concur. Good call.

Antonella is also being pimped out by Vote For The Worst, along with Sundance.

She goes to Catholic University in DC - they don't have Greek Life. Though sort of ironic she goes to a Catholic school and yet has lewd pics all over the internet. Not very Chrisitan of her...:p

OMG...THANK YOU AMERICA!!! I'm on Central Time; and I know the Eastern Time folks are watching with me...so I don't want to spoil it for the people don't get to watch it live...but it's 7:37 here and if you're watching who just got the boot like I did I'm sure you're just as happy!!!!!

ETA: The next person that left after the one above should NOT have gone. America got that one wrong!

ETA a 2nd time: Um...what is America thinking??? Okay, person #4 voted off is not my favorite but he was WORLD'S better than who got in over him. To quote Simon when asked what happened "America had the volume turned down".

100% COSIGN!!! WTF was America thinking? :mad: :confused:

At least Antonella is gone but how is Sanjaya still there? I can't believe Sabrina is gone. I really hope that the first one gone from the top 12 is Sanjaya and then Haley the week after.

I don't want to spoil it for people who haven't seen it yet, but so many of those 12 do NOT deserve to be there!!!!!!

That's just messed up. Don't folks have ears??

What America got wrong:
- Sunjaya should have left and Jared should have stayed
- Haley should have left and Sabrina should have stayed

Glad Antonella and Sundance are gone though.

Also, not to sound insensitive, but a donation to charity day is the BIG SURPRISE that they've been hyping?!? I though they were bringing someone back, or the judges were going to cut two people on the spot, etc. Charity is not a surprise, it's a positive gesture.

I like Haley. I'm glad she made it to the Top 12.

^^^ exactly!

I was glad Sundance was gone because I think it would have been much harder to get rid of him once he made it to the top 12. I don't think Sanjaya will last much longer.

:SMH: about the Sabrina/Haley thing

I agree. She's not that bad. We've definitely seen worse.

Sabrina wasn't horrible, either -- but she had a cheese factor that I didn't like.

So this donation to charity was the big deal they were talking about? I didn't get to watch last night's results show so I have no idea what the special announcement was.

Please I like that she seems.. softer, I guess. There's that whole Melinda/LaKisha big, powerful, voice mold and she's different than that. It's nice to have variety.

I kind of like her too - I think she's spunky. I think Sabrina fell victim to the fact that there are several "big voice" women in the competition - I think they're probably splitting votes.

Sabrina didn't stand out to me as much as the other big voices in the competition. However, I still would have sent Haley home before Sabrina.

And don't EVEN get me started on Sanjaya!!! Grrrr my friends and I were all yelling at the TV when Ryan said that Sanjaya made it.:mad:

Do you guys watch American Idol Rewind? I didn't bother at first because I thought it was just outtakes of the really horrible contestants from seasons past.

I managed to catch it last Saturday and found that they're re-airing the performance episodes from Season 1. It's so weird to see how different AI is now. The semi-final round is 200% more glamorous than when Kelly and Justin and the rest of the Season 1 contestants performed.

I liked Sundance :(

But I'm glad Chris S is still in!

Melinda looks very strange to me. She looks like a 40-something year old woman. I can't believe that she is only in her late twenties - she does NOT look like it. I don't know - there is just something bizarre about her appearance. And I really feel like there is Fanfasia Jr on the stage when Stephanie sings. All she needs is to say she goes to church to "get her sang on" and throw in some "yeah yeah yeah yeah's" -- she reminds me of Fanfasia so much.

(OTW - remember raising hell over Fanfasia - ah, the good 'ol days :D )

Oh, and I know by saying this she will either win or be in the top 3 - but I cannot STAND Gina - ugh ugh ugh - I like absolutely nothing about her.

Yes...Fanfasia. Still don't like her and just about barfed when Lifetime decided to do an autobiopic about her life.

And Melinda..I like.

But she has no neck.