GreekChat.com Forums

GreekChat.com Forums (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/index.php)
-   Greek Life (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   Question about Asian GLOs (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/showthread.php?t=65253)

Private I 04-12-2005 11:57 AM

WHY...

the need for political correctness, or 'diversity' by NPC/IFC org's...people gotta understand that people will join whatever org they feel comfortable in...whatever color they are! why the need for competition to see who will get get bragging rights for the most minorities?
(note: NOT addressed to everyone)

I'll never forget when I had dinner with one of my friend's parents...and we were discussing how I was a member of a multicultural sorority...and they were saying how their son was a member of a multicultural fraternity too...because it had 2 black members...

Taualumna 04-12-2005 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Private I
WHY...

the need for political correctness, or 'diversity' by NPC/IFC org's...people gotta understand that people will join whatever org they feel comfortable in...whatever color they are! why the need for competition to see who will get get bragging rights for the most minorities?
(note: NOT addressed to everyone)


I think many historically white GLOs want to rid themselves of the image that they're white only. GLOs are not the only groups who're trying to do that. Many other organizations are trying too, and often recruitment of minorities aren't easy because of language difficulties.

WhirlwindTNX 04-12-2005 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
I think many historically white GLOs want to rid themselves of the image that they're white only. GLOs are not the only groups who're trying to do that. Many other organizations are trying too, and often recruitment of minorities aren't easy because of language difficulties.

But what my Soror is trying to point out is that this is wrong. It's not cool to recruit only for the sole purpose of wanting to rid the "White only" image because then whatever minorities are recruited aren't actually sisters, they are just good PR.

Taualumna 04-12-2005 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by WhirlwindTNX
But what my Soror is trying to point out is that this is wrong. It's not cool to recruit only for the sole purpose of wanting to rid the "White only" image because then whatever minorities are recruited aren't actually sisters, they are just good PR.
I don't think there really are any schools that specifically target minorities, but at the same time, they do not want to be seen as predominantly white groups.

LatinaAlumna 04-12-2005 06:01 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
Many other organizations are trying too, and often recruitment of minorities aren't easy because of language difficulties.
Language has nothing to do with it. I can't believe I am reading this comment. You are saying that it is hard for NPC to recruit minority students because they don't speak English? I have never heard of this in my LIFE. I would say that most of the Latino, Asian, African American, etc. students at my university spoke English very well. What university do/did you attend where the minority students have such a widespread language problem that it affected your recruitment activities? We are not talking about the world population at large--we are talking about university women here. Again, language has nothing to do with women not joining NPC.

Taualumna 04-12-2005 06:18 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by LatinaAlumna
Language has nothing to do with it. I can't believe I am reading this comment. You are saying that it is hard for NPC to recruit minority students because they don't speak English? I have never heard of this in my LIFE. I would say that most of the Latino, Asian, African American, etc. students at my university spoke English very well. What university do/did you attend where the minority students have such a widespread language problem that it affected your recruitment activities? We are not talking about the world population at large--we are talking about university women here. Again, language has nothing to do with women not joining NPC.
Lots of minority students don't speak English outside of school and may not feel very comfortable joining clubs that are English speaking. This is from personal experience: In high school, the many of the Asian students (I would say the majority) are boarders from Hong Kong and Taiwan and would never interact with English speakers (including Asians) outside of class time/class projects. People who don't want to speak English outside of school/work are less likely to gravitate towards organizations that do.

At my non-Greek undergrad school, there were several cultural clubs aimed at Asians, including at least five or six for Chinese students (some Cantonese speaking, some Mandarin). Most of these clubs printed their ads in Chinese only. If you didn't read Chinese, but were still interested in joining an Asian interest club, there were other options for you.

preciousjeni 04-12-2005 06:27 PM

1) There is a pretty large population of Nigerians in the Atlanta area. A number of women who joined our chapters there were Nigerian. They have mentioned that they get frustrated with people who don't understand them - which is why they joined Theta Nu Xi. We don't seem to have an issue recruiting people whose first language is not English.

How is this a problem for NPCs on your campus?

2) No one has yet answered the question I continue to ask. Why do some people on this board say that NPCs want to shed their "predominantly white" label? Why is it so bad? It's your HISTORY!
  • A) With the number of white members these organizations have, it would take a huge effort to recruit enough non-white new members to make a dent in the population.
  • B) If you know your organization has diversity, why do you feel the need to explain yourself to others outside your organization. You don't owe anyone anything.
3) Yes it's redundant but people will join what they want to join. I'll tell you this right now, if a woman came up to me and expressed interest in my organization - but gave me the impression that she just wanted the letters but not the commitment - she would NOT become a member. I can pretty much guarantee that any nonsense like that happening in my presence would end up with a very sad and rejected interest. I don't play.

LatinaAlumna 04-12-2005 06:27 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
Lots of minority students don't speak English outside of school and may not feel very comfortable joining clubs that are English speaking. This is from personal experience: In high school, the many of the Asian students (I would say the majority) are boarders from Hong Kong and Taiwan and would never interact with English speakers (including Asians) outside of class time/class projects. People who don't want to speak English outside of school/work are less likely to gravitate towards organizations that do.

At my non-Greek undergrad school, there were several cultural clubs aimed at Asians, including at least five or six for Chinese students (some Cantonese speaking, some Mandarin). Most of these clubs printed their ads in Chinese only. If you didn't read Chinese, but were still interested in joining an Asian interest club, there were other options for you.

This might be true for some segment of a college population, but here we are discussing minority women who are seeking sorority membership, and why they do or don't go NPC. However, to address your reply here, I think you are making a very broad generalization about people who speak other languages (your reference to the "fact" that people who don't like to speak English will be less likely to gravitate towards organizations that do). I knew of several Latinas at my university that joined Chi Omega, and according to them, they spoke Spanish all the time at the house. Apparently they did not prefer to speak English outside of school, but yet they still joined an "English speaking" organization because that is the sorority they wanted to be a part of. They didn't let this "language" thing that you are describing stop them.

Unregistered- 04-12-2005 06:31 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
I don't think there really are any schools that specifically target minorities, but at the same time, they do not want to be seen as predominantly white groups.
Please don't make it seem like you speak for these campuses or the NPC, because you DON'T.

preciousjeni 04-12-2005 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by preciousjeni
No one has yet answered the question I continue to ask. Why do some people on this board say that NPCs want to shed their "predominantly white" label? Why is it so bad? It's your HISTORY!
Yeah, I'm quoting myself. :o It's a little embarassing. LOL! Anyway, the reason NPCs don't attract the number of non-white you seem to wish for, TauAlumna, may not simply be because NPCs are considered predominantly white.

Have you thought about other differences? Perhaps people are looking for organizations that take smaller pledge classes/lines. Perhaps they want an organization that gets very involved in local hands-on service. Perhaps the history of the org appeals to them. Perhaps the mission of the org does too.

This argument makes it seem that there is little distinction among NPCs groups and people actually choose the org they want to join based on the people in the chapters. But, that would be crazy! You join the entire organization. Falling in like with the people in your chapter is just an added perk.

Taualumna 04-12-2005 06:36 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by LatinaAlumna
This might be true for some segment of a college population, but here we are discussing minority women who are seeking sorority membership, and why they do or don't go NPC. However, to address your reply here, I think you are making a very broad generalization about people who speak other languages (your reference to the "fact" that people who don't like to speak English will be less likely to gravitate towards organizations that do). I knew of several Latinas at my university that joined Chi Omega, and according to them, they spoke Spanish all the time at the house. Apparently they did not prefer to speak English outside of school, but yet they still joined an "English speaking" organization because that is the sorority they wanted to be a part of. They didn't let this "language" thing that you are describing stop them.
While you might see the language issue as a "broad generalization," it's actually based on my own personal experience. Growing up, the Asian students at school just didn't join clubs that required lots of speaking. You'd rarely find a Chinese girl in the debating or drama club at my high school. There were times when I was the token Asian in drama. Oddly enough, the choir was half Asian. Band was very Asian. Art was also very Asian, and Classics more white. I found that this pattern reflected when I was an undergraduate.

LatinaAlumna 04-12-2005 06:40 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by OohTeenyWahine
Please don't make it seem like you speak for these campuses or the NPC, because you DON'T.

Thank you!

And Tau: If you are a "minority," please don't speak for all of "us" either, and if you are not a "minority", please don't tell "us" why we aren't joining NPC in record numbers. We're over here telling everyone why this isn't happening, but you keep coming back with your own theories (i.e., it's because of all the ethnic greeks, it's because of the language barrier).

LatinaAlumna 04-12-2005 06:41 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
While you might see the language issue as a "broad generalization," it's actually based on my own personal experience. Growing up, the Asian students at school just didn't join clubs that required lots of speaking. You'd rarely find a Chinese girl in the debating or drama club at my high school. There were times when I was the token Asian in drama. Oddly enough, the choir was half Asian. Band was very Asian. Art was also very Asian, and Classics more white. I found that this pattern reflected when I was an undergraduate.
Okay...but your personal experience still doesn't make it true for everyone.

Taualumna 04-12-2005 07:02 PM

I guess I just have issues....."jook sing mui" (hollow bamboo girl: Not Chinese, not "Western" either) as they say in Cantonese.....

Also known as "Banana" and "twinkie"......

now back to our regularly scheduled program

starang21 04-12-2005 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
I think many historically white GLOs want to rid themselves of the image that they're white only. GLOs are not the only groups who're trying to do that. Many other organizations are trying too, and often recruitment of minorities aren't easy because of language difficulties.
so you're looking for tokens.

starang21 04-12-2005 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Taualumna
I guess I just have issues....."jook sing mui" (hollow bamboo girl: Not Chinese, not "Western" either) as they say in Cantonese.....

Also known as "Banana" and "twinkie"......

now back to our regularly scheduled program

so you admit that you're white-washed.

interesting.......

ladygreek 04-13-2005 01:44 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by starang21
so you admit that you're white-washed.

interesting.......

And you my dear are Black-washed *running out of the thread before Starang snatches me, yelling back*

and you know I lub you for it. :D

starang21 04-13-2005 08:27 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by ladygreek
And you my dear are Black-washed *running out of the thread before Starang snatches me, yelling back*

and you know I lub you for it. :D

i'm not black??????


*goes to look in the mirror right quick*




:cool:


don't play, you know you've always wanted an asian son.

:D

RACooper 04-14-2005 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by LatinaAlumna
Language has nothing to do with it. I can't believe I am reading this comment. You are saying that it is hard for NPC to recruit minority students because they don't speak English? I have never heard of this in my LIFE. I would say that most of the Latino, Asian, African American, etc. students at my university spoke English very well. What university do/did you attend where the minority students have such a widespread language problem that it affected your recruitment activities? We are not talking about the world population at large--we are talking about university women here. Again, language has nothing to do with women not joining NPC.
Sorry but I have to step in and defend Taualumna....

Based on her perspective and greek experience language is most definately an issue when it comes to recruitment - in the enviroment that she is most familiar with.

Having been involved in both student politics and greek recruitment at the same campus I can attest to the difficulties in fully explaining aspects of student-life and greek-life to students that have English as a second or third language. I the case of our campus, a significant segment of students interested in getting involved in the university experience (basically any involvement in campus life other than studies) are first generation, or international students - and in many cases language does come up as not a barrier but rather a complication (terminology or even simple misunderstandings). It is significantly easier to recruit when you aren't struggling for words/terms to properly explain greek-life or educate someone about your chapter...

That all being said some of the more dedicated members of my chapter where Brothers that didn't have English as their native language - so I have been more than happy to take the extra time and effort invovled that may be needed with a PNM that is struggling with English.

DSTCHAOS 04-14-2005 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by RACooper
first generation, or international students
I think this distinction is the cause for most of the miscommunication in this thread.

ladygreek 04-14-2005 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by starang21
i'm not black??????


*goes to look in the mirror right quick*




:cool:


don't play, you know you've always wanted an asian son.

:D

Yep, and now I have one. :D

HBADPi 04-14-2005 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by BobbyTheDon

I just need some better luck with the persian girls. But I think Rudey is gonna help me out in that department. HBADPi hasn't done shit to help this brutha out. I think because she doesnt want to hook me up with any cal poly persian fobs. If thats the case, good lookin out.

Dude, you REALLY dont want the persian fobs at cal poly. I've hung out with them, believe me not soemthing you'd be interested in. I honestly dont know that many Persians, and I have mostly male cousins so I doubt that will help you much.

Once school's done I'll take you down to that Persian club on sunset even though I swore I'd never go back there again, I'll help your sorry ass out ;). I just need to make sure I have enough drinks in my system to make it through that experience again. Oh and theres on in Irvine apparently too (suprise suprise).

Sistermadly 04-15-2005 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by RACooper
Having been involved in both student politics and greek recruitment at the same campus I can attest to the difficulties in fully explaining aspects of student-life and greek-life to students that have English as a second or third language.
Or their parents. Oy, what a challenge.

preciousjeni 04-15-2005 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by HBADPi
fobs
:o When will this term just die?

RACooper 04-19-2005 04:17 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Sistermadly
Or their parents. Oy, what a challenge.
Yep... I remember many a longgggg discussion with concerned parents... discussions that may have been shorter (and more productive) if we could have more effectively understood each other...


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.