This special is so shady. Corey is just trying to be a fame whore to pimp out his album

She'll probably win the whole thing. That's a 19E given. I don't agree with it because she's got the stage presense of a robot, but she's got a good radio voice.

I haven't watched it... but I have to go to sleep early anyway and would have missed it. So YAY for Scott going home finally. I too will take another week of Diet Clay. At least he's easier on the eyes.

LOL at Eric Cartman.

Corey is such a publicity whore. He's trying to revive his "career" after being booted from the show for beating up his sister.

I think that Vonzell, Carrie and Bo are equally good in their own genres and that all will be very successful. I'd buy CDs by any of them (least likely Bo, but it depends .. not into the heavy rock anymore, so if he does mainstream stuff, like Heaven, I like it). I think they could be co-Idols.

My daughter confessed that she thinks Anthony is really cute. I told her I didn't think he was cute, but I could see why 11 year old girls would think that. She said "At least 3 girls in my class think he's cute, guess which 3?" I named a couple of her friends and she said "No, Me, Myself and I!". LOL She cracked me up.

I'm so glad Scott is gone.

The whole Fallen Idol show sounded like sour grapes from losers to me. Now, I was browsing here while it was on, but the parts I heard said that Paula was coaching Corey and talking about how great he is. Has Paula ever said anything bad about any contestant???? She always lavishes praise on them.. all of them! I don't think the special lived up to the hype. Just a sweeps month attempt at getting people to watch it. Nothing more.

Dee

I cannot believe I actually sat through this Corey Clark BS. If his claims are indeed true, why now? Oh that's right...he has a CD coming out in the near future.

I wasn't too surprised to see Jordan Segundo (Top 32-Season 2) brought in to discuss the allegations. Jordan, I love you and I think you're very talented, but you know and I know you're only on national TV because you just released YOUR CD as well! :p

Oh, and did anyone else think that Mrs. Clark looked a LOT like Julianna Marguiles?

I watched the Fallen Idol special last night and I still think it's totally BS. Did anyone who watched it notice that whenever they asked Corey if he slept with Paula, he said yes as he looked down at the floor?

As for his evidence...
1) "Witnesses" - it's easy to get your friends and family to lie for you.
2) "Pill Bottle" - you can easily print a prescription label off your computer.
3) Details of Paula's Home - she has been featured in InStyle and other places; it wouldn't be that hard to find pictures of her house.
4) Money for clothes - The contestants each get something like $700 spending money for clothes, etc.
5) Voicemails - They all came after he was shopping his book deal; all that proves is that she called to tell him to stop lying about her.

What I would have liked to have seen is someone from Season 2's final 12. Reportedly, when you make the final 12 you're closed up in the Idol house or you're busy doing Idol rehearsals/commercials ALL THE TIME. I would think if he was really sneaking around with Paula every night, someone else in the Top 12 would have seen something.

LOL. So true!

"Screw you guys, I'm going home."

I don't even remember him being on the show in the first place so WHY would I care about what he's saying now??:rolleyes:
I thought he looked like a crook with that hat on his head.

Yes, finally *someone* got the top 3 right. Now let's just make sure Anthony sings his farewell song next week!

SATX*APhi - I like Carrie, but she is just very run-of-the-mill for me. I mean, I like country, and I like her voice. And I would probably own her album. But Bo and Vonzell are just different to me - they both bring a different stage presence to an otherwise boring show. I think I like Vonzell especially because, like Clay, she has done every single thing the judges have recommended during the past weeks. They tell her to do XYZ, and by the next week, she has it down pat.

My only fear for Bo is that I don't see him singing on a cookie-cutter album that is no doubt already sitting on the shelf from 19E just waiting for a voice. I love Clay, but his album was clearly nothing from his own hand - which is why I am looking forward to the new one out later this year!

I watched the Corey thing too...well half of it anyway.

While some of his 'proof' was a little iffy, the one thing that did seem semi-legit was the phone bill from his parents house. There were a LOT of calls that went between there! If he is lying, then his parents are lying, and that's just wrong! I would never lie for my kids on something like that! ESPECIALLY on national television! Did anyone else notice Jessica Simpson's dad producing the album? We all know what a publicity whore HE is! LOL!

But they never actually proved that the phone number was Paula's.
Yes, he made a lot of calls, but it could have been to anyone.

I must have missed the part that said it wasn't 'proven' to be her number. That's kind of dumb that they'd put that out there then! That's something that could easily be shown...disconnected or not!

I thought Scott was a little bit better than Anthony. But that's pretty much none and void since Scott got kicked off.

There was something about Scott that scared the shit outta me. It wasn't the fact that his stature was a little bit bigger than the other contestants, he just didn't have the same "inviting" persona that I guess Ruben had.

If American Idol was all about closing your eyes while listening to the contestants perform, then Scott would have had a chance, I think. I had to change channels everytime he was up.