![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
You can be racially black and ethnically Carribbean or African, or European, or just plain American. |
Right, but what I'm talking about is the idea that diversity adds something to a university. I really don't see how black people lacking some advantage enjoyed by whites would add anything overly valuable. Diversity to me would mean an array of ideas and backgrounds. I simply fail to see how raising the black population of a school from 6% to 10% would accomplish that. Sure, the additional black students may have different ideas and backgrounds, but so would the white people they're replacing. I'm not attempting to make this into an affirmative action debate, I just think our society's ideas about diversity are fairly skewed.
|
Quote:
Quote:
So what you're saying isn't in constrast to what I said so I will remember not to repeat myself. ;) |
Quote:
Do you automatically think "affirmative action" when you see blacks at predominantly white institutions? :) |
No, but I automatically think "affirmative action" when discussing universities trying to increase the on-campus diversity.
|
Quote:
The whites don't own those applicant slots in the first place. So a literal "replacing" of whites is taking place but that wording is a bit disturbing to me. But truth be told "affirmative action" (in the broad sense) has been used for decades to keep some institutions predominently white. ;) |
You're right, whites don't own those spots. However, the majority of qualified applicants applying to good schools are white. Likewise, the majority of qualified applicants getting rejected are white. The simple fact is that affirmative action has kept white applicants from being accepted. The question is whether less qualified minorities have been given their "spot." I imagine the answer is yes, but that isn't my immediate concern. Schools in the past have been fairly open about accepting the minority candidate over a white one when their qualifications are identical. In the UM case, the school claimed this was to foster diversity on campus, which can provide an environment conducive for education. However, my opinion is that such practices constitute racial discrimination, and that the practices do not serve the purpose of "fostering diversity" any better than accepting the white applicant would, considering the broad diversity that exists among whites.
|
Quote:
I went to college with kids like you, they took one look at me in engineering courses and decided I was there because of affirmative action, when in actuality, I didn't have a single "minority" scholarship, but I had a bunch because I was an out-of-state student. |
Quote:
So back to the topic of achieving diversity. Affirmative action is simply ONE of the means through which diversity is achieved so no need to continue down that road. I just wanted to ask why you brought up affirmative action. ;) |
I brought up affirmative action because its become a blanket term used to describe efforts by universities to increase diversity. I imagine you'll agree with my version of its usage. As for opportunity hoarding, I imagine this is some effort by you to justify the racial discrimination against some whites in the application process, but it holds little weight with me.
To jubilence, who obviously saw the first few lines of my post and jumped to conclusions, i'd like to ask where I said all minorities are admitted because a white kid got screwed. This will probably take you a while, considering I didn't say it, nor did I even come remotely close to implying it. Better luck next time. |
Quote:
Quote:
Try again. |
Quote:
Quote:
I don't consider the leveling of the playing field to be "(reverse) racial discrimination," anyway. I think whites' complaints of reverse racial discrimination are self-important, presumptive and audacious. Quote:
She saw that you leaped from "diversity" to "affirmative action." Her conclusion is the same as when I asked you about seeing black students and automatically thinking "affirmative action." It's your fault...better luck next time. ;) |
Quote:
Jubilance, and all the rest of you on here who are minority women in engineering and sciences, you all take a lot of crap and you all amaze me. I could never have lasted at my engineering undergrad if I hadn't been holed up in my little liberal arts major haven, and I only have one strike against me. |
I've pretty much not been involved in this conversation, but I do take offense to being told exactly who I identify with and such. The idea that you only identify with those inside your own race is stupid, exclusionary, and biased. And the idea that race necessarily tops ethnicity, especially in white people, is equally stupid.
|
Quote:
I think one thing that is important to remember, however, is that when ethnicity does become an issue with white people, it can often be perceived negatively. Especially in the case of Italian-Americans, who are often stereotyped and treated unfairly by the media. So I can see how this would be an important issue for you. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I agree. But Italian Americans are still given the opportunity to either downplay or "up"play their Italian heritage. Either case they can identify as white and receive the same privileges as other whites in most social contexts. Italian Americans can even receive the utmost privilege in places with huge concentrations of Italian Americans. |
You're being ridiculous. There is very little distinction in affirmative action as it is practiced today, and diversity seeking universities. Don't believe me? Go look at the UM Supreme Court cases portrayed in the media as "affirmative action cases."
How is reverse discrimination audacious? The fact that you refuse to recognize it is pretty outrageous in my mind. What you're telling me is that its ok for a university to accept a black candidate over an equally qualified white person simply because they're black. You're right, thats not reverse discrimination at all... As for "leveling the playing field," you'll have to look other places. White people aren't holding the black community down. I highly suspect your blaming of the problems on institutionalized racism aren't aiding the rise of the black community either. Again, about me "implying" that all minorities are only in school in place of white people, I never even came close to saying that. Try as you might, me saying that it HAS happened is in no way similar to me saying it ALWAYS happens. I figured you two would understand that, but perhaps my confidence has been misplaced. |
Quote:
I know it's not all about "ME." But us wops have feelings too. Ethnic groups haven't exactly chosen when they get to integrate into mainstream American culture. Saying things like "they can identify as white" and thus recieve white priviliges implies that it is a choice. I don't identify as "white" White means nothing to me. I identify as Italian and as American. My children will likely identify as German and Italian or as just plain American. American does not equal white it means that I feel attached to the country I was born in. /And that I like Americanized versions of other countries' foods. //I'd still be a wop in some eyes. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I am so confused...
Why am not amazed at little pledges from the University of Georgia showing naked women who happen to be of Afrikan descent to the public driving down the street? shinerbock- You know you ain't got no Black friends anyway, so what's up with the vehemenence? Sistahgirl DSTChaos just called your bluff and you need to be a man about it... What's going to happen is you are gonna go off into a "hissy fit", "huff and puff", yell at all your little friends about Black people in Dekalb County, Stone Mountain, Georgia, where my cop, brother in law might have to take you to lockdown, 'cuz you missed your Klan rally up at the top of Stone Mountain... If you want to hate baby, that's okay... You ain't got no game or skillz, but you can hate... Which is probably the whole point to this pointless act. It just goes to show you that the Chi Phi pledges at UGA have no game or skillz and they have to show naked ladies to folks driving down to street to get some... |
Now I'm confused. :confused:
|
Quote:
And you're right, it definately has some characters...but there are some great folks there too. |
Wow, I can't believe that you all actually had classmates that told you that crap to your face. :eek:
|
Quote:
|
Seriously AKA, I have no idea what you're talking about. If you're referring to your friend attempting to justify reverse racism, then thats fine, but I'm not quite sure.
I'm not sure what you mean by "my leap," so I can't fully answer your question. As far as I'm concerned, there is no "leap" involved. Its simply that you believe a black student should get into a school before an equally qualified white person, simply because of race. As for affirmative action, theres no use debating what it is and what it isn't. I apologize if I don't recognize your definition over the likes of CNN or MSNBC...while I give you credit for being at least marginally intelligent, I'm not sure my regard can be extended that far. I think our fundamental difference in ideology is that while I think applicants should be admitted on merit, you feel some people should be given preferential treatment. I guess we're just different. Starang, I find your comments regarding the bell curve funny...especially since the comment you are agreeing with was a completely erroneous assumption. |
Quote:
It's just always amazed me the attitudes of some of those people ... especially the difference from when I was in my major classes (literature, history, etc.) and when I was in my science and math courses. Some people would say to your face that you only got in because you were a girl. Women would even say it about themselves - I guess they thought self-depreciation was cute. I think one of the biggest problems in universities today is the divisions between students over stuff like that, and my undergrad/your grad seemed to really accentuate those divisions a lot. I think they're starting to improve, tho'. Just always pissed me off ... I had better credentials on my admissions application than my SO the Rocket Scientist, but no one ever challenged him on any kind of affirmative action stuff :mad: |
Quote:
|
Quote:
I'll let you search my posts from the last few years to see my "marginal intelligence" has put me. But, I guess what counts is "emotional intelligence" and "social intelligence" and you are not the sharpest tool in the chest here, now are you... I do dare you to start posting how much you really love and enjoy Black women on the Alpha Kappa Alpha Sorority, Inc. "avenue" on GC. Good luck with that... Oh, and actually, I am not that young. I am around Earp's age... |
Quote:
After reading your last response.....I am somewhat interested to know what it is that you do. I don't care the least bit to search "over the years" to see what it is......something though is telling me that it really isn't that big of a deal....at all. Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I guess helping large populations of people, given that heart disease is the number one killer in America "really isn't a big of a deal...at all". I guess I should just quit because affirmative action gave me this opportunity and I am worthless because I took advangtage of this chance to succeed and be a positive contributing member of society that pays my taxes. Quote:
So, I wonder who is less intelligent, especially when the "word on the streets" are ignored simply because it is viewed as deficient. But hey, I am accustomed to be discounted and ruled out of the life "competition". I just dust myself off and say "bring it on..." |
Quote:
Actually I didn't identify it wrong saying that it was ebonics. Quote:
|
Quote:
But I am nearing 40 years old. I have never been pregnant. I am not struggling with some fool who has been incarcerated. And I am not a substance abuser. I have had plenty encounters with those types of African American women. And in my Sorority and church work, I have tried to change some of these women's lives. In fact, I have had tried to change the lives of young ladies by showing them a better choice that living in destitution. That is what I deal with constantly. And I can speak for plenty of other African American women who post here that they probably work to change the lives of those in their community, too. Quote:
|
I would just like to say that I HATE the term "reverse racism". Racism is racism no matter who its againwst. Reverse racism would be like... unracism, or something.
|
Quote:
I got that from Wikipedia. You can also go to www.cal.org.....which is the Center for Applied Linguistics, and you will find that African American Vernacular English is commonly referred to as Ebonics. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:07 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.