GreekChat.com Forums

GreekChat.com Forums (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/index.php)
-   Greek Life (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   Rejected black rushee starts "multi-cultural" GLO at AL (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/showthread.php?t=22309)

sigmagrrl 08-21-2002 01:23 PM

I'm also an Arican American woman in an NPC sorority. First, my race actually never came to mind when I went thru recruitment, because there were already other African Americans in the NPC's on my campus. Plus, being from the Northeast, I never think race first. My first thought, actually, was appearance: was I pretty enough...

What I think happens is that NPC is never really "marketed" to us by our relations, so we don't think NPC first when we go to college. Also, as sad as it is, "race mixing" (yes, it sounds as oogy as the thought makes you feel) is still an unheard of notion in the mind of people today, so you may HAVE friends of another race, but deep, intense familial bonding with them is still foreign. You won't readily admit it, but it is.

I'm not speaking about anyone on this board, just in generalities. I know that the South still has some very racist areas, but racists are everywhere (there are these new fangled contraptions called cars and planes!!). But so are anti-Semites, homophobes, and a$$holes in general. If you can keep these disgusting characteristics out of your head and home, you may be a catalyst for change!

James 08-21-2002 01:57 PM

Specific to this issue:

The problem that most people had initially with this situation, before the various tangents were explored, is the difference between being offended by the actions of the young men in question (I am referring to he Holloween Party now) and an agency taking "official" steps.

Be offended, be outraged, take social steps to punish the chapter. That is all good.

But don't have a government or authority type agency such as a University step in and punish them for a Consitutionally protected activity just because you believe that specific application of that activity is bad.

Because that opens the door to some agency punishing you for an expression that others don't approve.

Keep in mind that the same agencies that we applaud for punishing this group were not very nice to Civil Rights Activists not that many years ago. But at the time popular opinion supported them . . . like it does here.

Fashions change. That is why we have laws that are supposed to protect us at all times.

We either protect everyone or no one.

auakl 08-21-2002 01:57 PM

Neicy,

Looks like we’re going to have to agree to disagree in large part on this one. It’s sad that we couldn’t have a calm discussion about a serious subject. But since you made a nice list (hey, you’re organized, I’ll give you that :))
Quote:

#1. With all due respect I could less about you being a proud alumna(lol), your wife, and your school. The point is that Alabama is still one of the most racist states.
I am proud of who I am and where I came from and whether you could care less doesn’t mean a thing to me, but thanks for reminding me how special the folks who do are to me. :) I hope you too can look back at your experiences and family and say that they have made you a better person overall. I give you a tip of the hat for catching the ‘alumna’ error, excuse me, proud alumnus – I won’t begin on your grammatical errors though (lol), good thing we’re all human and make mistakes. On a serious note, you harp on the idea that Alabama is one of the most racist states as your personal experience seems to have borne out. I will fully acknowledge that Alabama probably has more than its fair share of racist individuals, key word here is individuals, so if you want to call Alabama one of the most racist states, then I won’t argue with you on that point. I just object to your apparent characterizations of the state as a whole as such whether that was your intention or not. Again, we can agree to disagree.
On a related note, while I don’t think you can statistically track and plot on a map racism, you can track segregation which I would regard as an indication of general racial attitudes; please feel free to disagree, I don’t claim to be an expert on anything especially race relations, demographics, statistics or psychology. Please take a look at the following table that appeared in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel on May 9, 2001 of America’s most segregated cities generated from the 2000 census: http://www.jsonline.com/news/metro/may01/SEG09G2.asp
Notice that the three most segregated cities according to this study (rankings will certainly vary by study) are Detroit, Milwaukee and New York City. The first Southern city comes in at #10, Miami. Surprised? I sure was, and yes, medium sized Southern cities were included in the rankings. What does that prove? To you, probably nothing. But I see it as an indication that racism, prejudice and stereotyping knows no geographic boundaries, thanks for giving us a demonstration from the wonderful city of Chicago, one of my favorite cities for sports and museums...and number 6 on the above list.

Quote:

#2.How do you know the African American woman wasn't rejected because of her race?Were you there?Did you personally reject her?Or did you call one of the members and just took their good hearty word?Gosh I guess in 2002 it's so hard to believe that good old American Flag totin white sorority members would reject anyone based on race.
You asked, how do I know that the African American woman wasn't rejected because of her race? I don’t, never said I did. In fact I wrote that I thought it was likely that some individual sisters had voted against her because she was black. I really don’t see where you are coming from on this point. My argument is I don’t think she failed to receive a bid solely because she is black. I feel there were other factors in play beside race, an argument you seem to reject. I guess I would ask you a slightly refined version of the questions you asked me: How do you know the African American woman was rejected because of her race?Were you there?Did you personally witness people rejecting her?Or did you call her and just took her good hearty word? Again, it looks like we’ll just have to agree to disagree.

Quote:

#3 Please don't get give me that crap about me saying the whole state is racist. I said it is one of the most racist states.I guess it's hard for you to see that behind your Blublockers.Alabama is more racist than Illinois whether you can admit to it or not.Have fun hiding behind your Blublockers!
Wow! I guess I’m going to have to run out and buy me a pair of these BluBlockers to hide behind. :D I didn’t even know they existed until you mentioned them. This is the most ridiculous statement that I think you’ve written yet. I might not be having fun hiding behind my Blublockers, but I’m laughing now. For someone who hates stereotypes so much, you sure seem to hurl a lot of stereotypical statements. I guess I’ll have to trade in my New Balance shoes, khaki pants and sunglasses on a leash huh? Too bad I’ve never worn that “frat boy” outfit either. I’m sorry, back to the real issue at hand. I see that you are correct in stating that you said earlier that Alabama is one of the most racist states. I don’t think anyone here disagrees with your assessment that Alabama ranks right up there in number of racist people. Good grief, I even went out of my way to point out earlier that I believe Illinois probably (I haven’t spent enough time outside Chicago to get an informed opinion of the rest of the state, have you?) does not have as great a percentage of racist individuals as Alabama; see I didn’t even need to take off my BluBlockers for that. :) Yes, you never said the entire state was racist, however your comments, choice of words and tone were such that they seemed to condemn the people of the entire state, whether that was your intent or not, that was how I read it.

I hope those of you who have never been to Alabama take the chance to visit sometime and form your own opinion, not an opinion generated from the media or the experiences of a handful of people like neicy. I hope you will find a warm and friendly state that love visitors to come to our state parks, play our world renowned championship golf courses (in Alabama??? Yup, the Robert Trent Jones Golf Trail - http://www.rtjgolf.com/) and visit our historic sites including the Selma To Montgomery National Historic Trail (http://www.nps.gov/semo/) Yes, you will undoubtedly encounter folks you wouldn’t want to invite to dinner in your home, I’ve met these same folks everywhere I’ve been. But I firmly believe that you will find more good people than bad if you just take the time to sit down with them. I would like you to form your opinion based on your experiences, not from portrayals that may or may not be representative of the state as a whole.

I applaud those who recognize that racism, stereotypes and prejudices exist everywhere and are working to end it.

I wish the MCGLO the best and hope they make a positive impact on UA’s campus.

MysticCat81, I loved your comment about our right to say something stupid and to be rebuked for such, could not have said it better myself! :D

Swamp Thang, while we might not of always had the same interests and same ways of doing things (how boring would that be???), the brothers of the AU chapter of Omega Psi Phi I had the privilege of knowing were awesome and I thoroughly enjoyed being around them, I’m glad to hear that alumni such as yourself are staying involved. Keep guiding and molding upstanding young men.

Neicy, a final word and then I shall end this dialogue from my perspective, I wish you the best and hope you find somewhere positive to channel your emotions, with as much energy and passion you seem to have you could make a real difference somewhere.

Bamboozled 08-21-2002 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by auakl
Neicy,
Please take a look at the following table that appeared in the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel on May 9, 2001 of America’s most segregated cities generated from the 2000 census: http://www.jsonline.com/news/metro/may01/SEG09G2.asp
Notice that the three most segregated cities according to this study (rankings will certainly vary by study) are Detroit, Milwaukee and New York City. The first Southern city comes in at #10, Miami. Surprised? I sure was, and yes, medium sized Southern cities were included in the rankings. What does that prove? To you, probably nothing. But I see it as an indication that racism, prejudice and stereotyping knows no geographic boundaries, thanks for giving us a demonstration from the wonderful city of Chicago, one of my favorite cities for sports and museums...and number 6 on the above list.

Dang, I SWORE that I was going to stay out of this convo, so one post and I'm out....

Auak, please know that segregation deals largely with class and economics, not necassarily race. Chicago and other large cities are definitely segregated, but it's more by the haves and the have nots than by race. So, you may have blacks on one side of town and whites on another, but that's due to where each group can afford to live (which is a whole other topic all together). The difference is that if one of those black families moved into one of the "white" neighborhoods, I doubt they'd have to fear finding a cross burning on their front lawn.

auakl 08-21-2002 04:56 PM

Bamboozled,

Excellent points, now you see why I didn't profess to know all about such population statistics. :) What I was hoping to demonstrate (and maybe this was a poor example) is that division between groups exists everywhere, not just in the South. I will agree with you that class and economics play a TREMENDOUS role in how groups relate. I do believe that race and attitudes (i.e. sterotypes and prejudices) plays some part, as people tend to associate and live with folks that have common interests, backgrounds, problems, etc. Linking the statistics to racism itself was probably an error on my part. I think that your comments on demographics were a great insight on your part, thanks for the clarification.

PotentialPledge 08-21-2002 05:00 PM

I agree bamboozled. My aunt just moved to a predominately white neighborhood in Northern Virginia, and she has no worries. I guess some people might feel different elsewhere about moving into different neighborhoods.

Dionysus 08-21-2002 05:36 PM

Re: Dum Dum Ditty
 
Quote:

Originally posted by neicy81

This is where reading and comprehension comes into play.Yeah remember phonics and reading class from elementary ? I LIVED THERE FOR 2 YEARS SO YES I DO KNOW. My statistics come from my experiences.READ READ READ!

Personal experience isn't good enough, we need factual data to back up your claims.

Tom Earp 08-21-2002 06:01 PM

Well neicy81, I see you have reared your head again to stir up racisim among the GCers!

We ALL do not disagree with you, but you seem to disagree with ALL of us!

You are the one who promigates all of the hatred that you profess is among all of us.

Is there still racial problems, will there always be problems between different races? Yes! And you for one do not help the situation at all.

You are one of the most racist people I have ever met anywhere!

You always attack everyone! It is your way or not any way at all!

You are not the Joan De Arc of Blackdom, yo are the Crown of thorns who want to prick everyone on site!

Get a life and figure out the first step is to learn how to mingle with people whether The color or religion they be.

Hitler used the Jewish people as a scape goat, just whom are you using?

I for one would like to see you spread your hatred somewhere else!

I know I will get a scathing response from you on this as YOU are The Only One on the site! DA!

I suggest everyone just ignor this and be on our way of trying to help each other in a more positive way.

This horse was beat to death on a previous site that you did, exactly the same thing! Do you feel sorry for the Dead Horse?

Dionysus 08-21-2002 06:07 PM

Re: Re: Re: Dum Dum Ditty
 
Quote:

Originally posted by neicy81



Are you a moderator?Oh thought I read wrong?!!

I was teasing you hun.

Dionysus 08-21-2002 06:10 PM

Why can't we all just get along?

You can't see black people at night, white people in the snow, Asians next to beer, nor mixed people by zebras. Everyone has their faults. :eek:

In other words this finger pointing has to stop if anyone wants to solve any problems, because we all are part of the problem in some ways.

SapphireSweetie 08-21-2002 06:13 PM

Hmmmmm
 
Quote:

Originally posted by neicy81


This is where reading and comprehension comes into play.Yeah remember phonics and reading class from elementary ? I LIVED THERE FOR 2 YEARS SO YES I DO KNOW. My statistics come from my experiences.READ READ READ!

Okay, I think we are seriously need to take a breath before someone gets hurt (LOL). First of all, everyone is entitled to their own opinions on everything. As auakl said, we "have to agree to disagree," which is the foundation in ANY discussion.

I'm kinda gonna do a lil devil's advocate over here and try to point things out objectively. Now, bout that NPC frat that dressed as Ques. Well there are 2 outlooks on that. One, they were just caught up in the Halloween fun and were being ignorant to PC. Or two, they were just being stupid.... I'm strongly leanin to the latter simply because it's plain disrespectful to sport letters of another GLO without permission, especially if you're going to add props that recall violent times in their history (i.e. the lynching props). I admit that I was upset when I heard this story, for I thought that their actions were going to reflect back to every WGLO, and I'm sad to say that ppl have taken it like that, rather than blaming the fault on just the individuals.

As for Ms. Twilley, is it really difficult to conclude that she might not have gotten along with the sisters? Granted, racism does exist and I'm not denying it. Everyone experiences bigotry, racism and stereotype at one point in their lives, but it is in not following those exemplifying those negative concepts can one truly end this nature of cyclic hatred.

Yet, I know that being a Filipina who strongly considered going into an NPHC sorority but went to an NPC sorority instead, that there are MAJOR differences in the voting/selection process. I know that during rush/recruitment, sisters are asked to consider not only the grades, accomplishments, etc, but they are also asked whether or not one would be proud to call the rushee a sister. As much as there are those standard requisites, there is still in consideration the person's attitude and behavior. And to be quite frank, we can't sit here and make speculations on why she wasn't accepted, it only adds to the propaganda that's already being circulated about her as well as the fact that it's adding to the concept that ALL WGLOs won't accept anyone but whites.

I know that I am fortunate that the "WGLO" that I'm in is not a strict "WGLO" -- as one, I'm in it; secondly, my little sister (who's a beautiful black woman if I might add) is in it; third, my big sister (who's indian and lovely) is in it; and finally, there is a diverse body of almost ALL races in my sorority, specifically my chapter.

Yet, who knows what really went down in that voting process? The important thing is that Ms. Twilley has found her niche and found the place that accepts her and she is happy with. Whether it is BGLO, MGLO, or WGLO, as long as the bonds exist and differences are respected where one is at is what's important.

Honeykiss1974 08-21-2002 06:14 PM

Pardon me for the station break.......
 
Just wondering Tom why the need to try and "call out" Neicy? :confused: Is it because you think she doesn't "play nice"? Is it because she is too agressive or because her opinion is not in agreement of the majority? So far, no one has resorted to name-calling or anything like that, so what is the REAL problem?. Everyone has different ways of debating her opinion. As has been said before if you don't like the topic of the thread, why check it?


She is not the only beating a dead horse. :o

Neicy is just one person, however that are PLENTY of folks responding to her. Apparently she IS NOT the only person who believes in the "my way or the highway" approach to their opinion. I don't see anyone else in here rushing to take her opinion as their own.
:rolleyes:

GREAT POST SAPPHIRE!!!:)

SapphireSweetie 08-21-2002 06:18 PM

WHOA Tom Earp!!! Imma suggest you take Dionysus' advice of "can't we all just get along." In callin niecy out like that you're just instigating and not helping.... constructive criticism is okay... destructive is another matter!!! :eek:

P.S. Thanks Honeykiss... I like your post too =)

Dionysus 08-21-2002 06:21 PM

Damn, it's going to get hot in here when neicy reads Tom's post, lol. I just hope nothing get's deleted before I get out of my night classes. :eek:

Honeykiss1974 08-21-2002 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dionysus
Damn, it's going to get hot in here when neicy reads Tom's post, lol. I just hope nothing get's deleted before I get out of my night classes. :eek:

Don't go to class tonite!

*lol*

:D


*lol*


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:19 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.