GreekChat.com Forums

GreekChat.com Forums (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/index.php)
-   Greek Life (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   UGa Chi Phis declared 'open season' on black women? (https://greekchat.com/gcforums/showthread.php?t=80632)

Soul D-Psi-ple 09-14-2006 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mulattogyrl (Post 1320567)
Hold up, you don't have to get smart with me. I just asked a question. You need to calm your ass down just a tad, for real. I asked that because I thought that's what we WERE talking about.

Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiit a minute now. I was actually being HONEST. It went from Racism and Sexism into Feminism. I think YOU need to calm down "just a tad", for real. Real talk, if I was going to get smart with you, I would have said something extremely "ignorant".

mulattogyrl 09-14-2006 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320579)
Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaiiiiiiiiiiit a minute now. I was actually being HONEST. It went from Racism and Sexism into Feminism. I think YOU need to calm down "just a tad", for real. Real talk, if I was going to get smart with you, I would have said something extremely "ignorant".

Quote:

Originally Posted by DSTCHAOS (Post 1320490)
We're actually still "on" (racial and) gendered stereotypes.

Forest through the trees, and all that good stuff.

^^^^^^^

Soul D-Psi-ple 09-14-2006 01:11 PM

And reason why you quoted her was because.....? :rolleyes:

shinerbock 09-14-2006 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320364)
The fact that YOU even said something....

Right, so basically you didn't answer the question. What does it being at UGA have anything to do with it? I hope you aren't insinuating that UGA is some backwoods redneck school, because if thats the case, you might head to the library and do some research.

MysticCat 09-14-2006 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320546)
I'd love to answer this, but to be honest, this little scenario you just layed down would never take place.

Translation: I would answer that, but it might show a lack of consistency and logic in what I have already said, so I think I'll just dodge the question altogether.

C'mon. If you say the UGA chapter of Chi Phi should be held accountable for the actions of their pledges, then would you also say that your chapter be held responsible for the actions of your probationary members? Saying, "it would never take place" is simply a dodge.

And interesting that you would say this:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320557)
Should the whole chapter be punished? No, but they will need to answer for these guys and they cleary did and are cooperating with the administration. If it was found that the chapter was behind this then, yea, they should be punished. Period.

I think most of us would agree with this.

But earlier, when many of us were asking why the entire chapter should be punished unless it could be shown that the chapter itself was behind what these guys did, you seemed quite willing to condemn the whole chapter simply because a few pledges "weren't mindful of their actions even they knew that OTHERS knew that they were associated with the UGA chapter of Chi Phi."

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1319927)
No, [removing the chapter] would not remove individual ignorance, but it would remove an organization from the campus that represents ignorance.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1319956)
When an organization does something truly STUPID and IGNORANT, and the administration takes notice of this, they have to do something about it.

So which is it? Should the chapter be punished only if the investigation shows the chapter was behind the pledges' actions, or should the chapter be punished regardless because it "represents ignorance"?

And by the way, I agree with you that racism is always wrong. I imagine Kevin does, too. But he's exactly right -- there are people who don't agree with the three of us on that. There are even people who think racism is the will of God. Kind of like how many people think abortion is always wrong and against the will of God, but others disagree with them.

Soul D-Psi-ple 09-14-2006 01:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1320592)
Right, so basically you didn't answer the question. What does it being at UGA have anything to do with it? I hope you aren't insinuating that UGA is some backwoods redneck school(you said this. not me.), because if thats the case, you might head to the library and do some research.

I've been to UGA PLENTY of times to form my opinion of it.

Elephant Walk 09-14-2006 01:20 PM

UGA is hardly backwoods. It takes too many fools from Atlanta to earn that honor.

mulattogyrl 09-14-2006 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320589)
And reason why you quoted her was because.....? :rolleyes:


*SIGH* Here you go, still getting smart. I'm not the arguing type. I thought if you saw it said a different way, you might understand what I was saying, that's all. Don't waste your time getting hyped up over what I type. Finish arguing with the rest of GC.

Soul D-Psi-ple 09-14-2006 01:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysticCat81 (Post 1320593)
Translation: I would answer that, but it might show a lack of consistency and logic in what I have already said, so I think I'll just dodge the question altogether.


C'mon. If you say the UGA chapter of Chi Phi should be held accountable for the actions of their pledges, then would you also say that your chapter be held responsible for the actions of your probationary members? Saying, "it would never take place" is simply a dodge.

It's not a dodge. Just know that it would not happen. If it did, then yea, we would have to answer for them. Now regarding drinking, nah. That's an individual thing I believe. If they get caught and none of us are involved, then thats on them. We just have to watch who we choose as our potential members ALOT more closely. But, like I said, that scenario would not happen. Just know that.

And interesting that you would say this:

I think most of us would agree with this.

But earlier, when many of us were asking why the entire chapter should be punished unless it could be shown that the chapter itself was behind what these guys did, you seemed quite willing to condemn the whole chapter simply because a few pledges "weren't mindful of their actions even they knew that OTHERS knew that they were associated with the UGA chapter of Chi Phi."



So which is it? Should the chapter be punished only if the investigation shows the chapter was behind the pledges' actions, or should the chapter be punished regardless because it "represents ignorance"?

No, they need to answer to the 'powers that be' regardless. If found that they are behind the stupidity then, yes. The chapter should be punished.

And by the way, I agree with you that racism is always wrong. I imagine Kevin does, too. But he's exactly right -- there are people who don't agree with the three of us on that. There are even people who think racism is the will of God. Kind of like how many people think abortion is always wrong and against the will of God, but others disagree with them.


Did I answer your questions a little better?

Soul D-Psi-ple 09-14-2006 01:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mulattogyrl (Post 1320606)
*SIGH* Here you go, still getting smart. I'm not the arguing type. I thought if you saw it said a different way, you might understand what I was saying, that's all. Don't waste your time getting hyped up over what I type. Finish arguing with the rest of GC.

Hey, it looked like you were the one getting smart with me. And I really not hyped up over anything. If it appeared as if I was getting smart with you, then I apologize. That's not my style. I don't start arguments. I just join them (those pertaining to debatable topics of course).

mulattogyrl 09-14-2006 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320615)
Hey, it looked like you were the one getting smart with me. And I really not hyped up over anything. If it appeared as if I was getting smart with you, then I apologize. That's not my style. I don't start arguments. I just join them (those pertaining to debatable topics of course).

That's cool. :cool:

Now, can somebody post something stupid so I can continue to laugh at it? Thanks.

MysticCat 09-14-2006 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320610)
Did I answer your questions a little better?

Perhaps, and thanks.

But I'm still trying to figure this out. You say of drinking: "That's an individual thing I believe. If they get caught and none of us are involved, then thats on them." Why isn't the same true here if it turns out that the pledges did this on their own, without chapter involvement or encouragement?

As an aside, it appears from reading a number of articles in UGA's The Red and Black that the chapter was suspended not because of the actions of the pledges per se, but because the University is investigating whether the pledges did what they did as a result of hazing. In other words, the investigation seems to be focused on possible hazing rather than on the incredibly stupid (at best) act itself.

AlphaFrog 09-14-2006 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mulattogyrl (Post 1320616)
Now, can somebody post something stupid so I can continue to laugh at it? Thanks.


http://www.stupid.com/Merchant2/grap...rlfork-pkg.jpg

Soul D-Psi-ple 09-14-2006 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MysticCat81 (Post 1320624)
Perhaps, and thanks.

But I'm still trying to figure this out. You say of drinking: "That's an individual thing I believe. If they get caught and none of us are involved, then thats on them." Why isn't the same true here if it turns out that the pledges did this on their own, without chapter involvement or encouragement?


As an aside, it appears from reading a number of articles in UGA's The Red and Black that the chapter was suspended not because of the actions of the pledges per se, but because the University is investigating whether the pledges did what they did as a result of hazing. In other words, the investigation seems to be focused on possible hazing rather than on the incredibly stupid (at best) act itself.

The same is true. It's unfortunate that they are suspended currently, however.


Hazing, hazing, hazing. When will folks learn. You can make potential members earn their letter through a THROROUGH MIP rather than hazing.

Elephant Walk 09-14-2006 02:11 PM

Minor in Possession?

I'm not a band g(r)eek, I don't know these things.

mulattogyrl 09-14-2006 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlphaFrog (Post 1320635)

LOL. Thanks!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elephant Walk (Post 1320648)
Minor in Possession?

I'm not a band g(r)eek, I don't know these things.

Tee hee. That was kinda funny.

macallan25 09-14-2006 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320596)
I've been to UGA PLENTY of times to form my opinion of it.


Your opinion is rather idiotic.

DSTCHAOS 09-14-2006 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Soul D-Psi-ple (Post 1320589)
And reason why you quoted her was because.....

...I answered your question yet you continued to think we were on an unrelated tangent.

DSTCHAOS 09-14-2006 02:39 PM

So, long story short:

1. Chi Phi is under investigation and yada yada yada.

2. Insert some confusion as to how we can extend a convo on naked black women to a response to a (gendered) stereotype on feminists. Different manifestation of the same general topic.

The End.

shinerbock 09-14-2006 05:04 PM

Yeah, when I said backwoods and redneck, I was referring to what uneducated views you probably had regarding the institution. UGA is pretty good school, and its far from backwoods. Athens is a pretty diverse town as well. I'd love to know what made you form your own opinion, given that you've visited here so many times.

DSTCHAOS 09-14-2006 07:27 PM

http://www.libs.uga.edu/athens/population.html
http://www.ersys.com/usa/13/1303440/ethnic.htm

Elephant Walk 09-14-2006 07:51 PM

What does the ethnic make up of the county/town have anything to do with the University. Athens does not equal UGA.

for example:
my hometown is probably 15% black, however one of the colleges in my hometown is over 30%. In fact, it has one of the largest step shows in the South.

DSTCHAOS 09-14-2006 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elephant Walk (Post 1320888)
What does the ethnic make up of the county/town have anything to do with the University. Athens does not equal UGA.

Because...


Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock
UGA is pretty good school, and its far from backwoods. Athens is a pretty diverse town as well.

Main point, UGA is just about as diverse (ethnically and otherwise) as Athens is. No college or university exists outside of its surroundings, unless it intentionally has greater representations of certain groups, although I could not find UGA's demographic breakdown on its website. The photos on UGA's website are probably indicative of the level of ethnic diversity there. *smile*

Either way, I have friends in doctoral programs there and they aren't too impressed with UGA's or Athens' ethnic and income diversity. However, Atlanta has a similar issue with diversity but the difference is that ATL has 300,000 more people and blacks outnumber other races and ethnicities. I happen to like UGA and think this Chi Phi story shouldn't reflect poorly on the University.

DSTCHAOS 09-14-2006 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elephant Walk (Post 1320888)
for example:
my hometown is probably 15% black, however one of the colleges in my hometown is over 30%. In fact, it has one of the largest step shows in the South.

:rolleyes:

EE-BO 09-14-2006 09:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DSTCHAOS (Post 1320486)
What did you supposedly say carefully and succinctly? Translation please.

Just pointing out that feminism as a major political movement is no longer relevant or necessary because the original goals have been largely achieved.

It does not mean the concept has lost all meaning or value, but it does mean that those who remain in a very militant mode have lost touch with mainstream society.

(in my opinion, that is.)

jon1856 09-14-2006 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elephant Walk (Post 1320888)
What does the ethnic make up of the county/town have anything to do with the University. Athens does not equal UGA.

for example:
my hometown is probably 15% black, however one of the colleges in my hometown is over 30%. In fact, it has one of the largest step shows in the South.

From Newsweek/Kaplan's How to get into College 2007 Edition:
University of Georgia
FT Undergrads 22,730
Men: 43%
Women: 57%
African-American 5%
Asian-American 5%
Latino 2%
Native-American <1%
Caucasian 86%
In Fraternities 18%
In Sororities 23%


And per: http://www.ope.ed.gov/security/InstI...asp?CRITERIA=H
in the years 2002, 2003, 2004 no hate crimes reported.

GC seems to have two threads on this-went back to re-read most of the other thread.
Without searching for or seeing other updated information, my limited POV is:
It would seem as if a group of young male students, who happened to be pledges of a Fraternity, committed this action.
Again without knowing all information, the only part the the chapter may have had in this was not knowing what their pledges were up to and/or teaching them about being Gentlemen.

As for the rest of this thread, I will just lurk about and read it.

Elephant Walk 09-14-2006 10:32 PM

Much less diverse than I had imagined. It's much like Arkansas though.

Elephant Walk 09-14-2006 10:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DSTCHAOS (Post 1320945)
:rolleyes:

There's a reason they call it "End of the World Party", Black Greeks across the state and throughout the south come down to my hometown to step.

shinerbock 09-14-2006 11:45 PM

Well the school doesn't have many black people, thats been in the news I imagine everyone's heard about that over the years...however Athens has plenty of black people, at least from what I see. As for the law school, I think its something like 30 percent minority, its pretty diverse. By the way, a simple lack of black people does not keep an area from being "diverse"...

DSTCHAOS 09-15-2006 12:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321097)
however Athens has plenty of black people, at least from what I see.

LOL.

jon1856 09-15-2006 12:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321097)
Well the school doesn't have many black people, thats been in the news I imagine everyone's heard about that over the years...however Athens has plenty of black people, at least from what I see. As for the law school, I think its something like 30 percent minority, its pretty diverse. By the way, a simple lack of black people does not keep an area from being "diverse"...

Shiner'
Looked it up for you:
http://www.law.uga.edu/news/archives...ngclasspr.html
Class of 2009: total of 232 students:"
Just over one-quarter (25.4 percent) of the entering class indicated they are members of a minority group, making this class among the most diverse in law school history. Of the 59 minority students enrolled in the Class of 2009, 37 are African Americans."

And the rest of your comment, for the most part, I agree with.

shinerbock 09-15-2006 12:48 AM

I think one quarter is pretty diverse, but then again I'm just one of the 173 whities.

DSTCHAOS 09-15-2006 10:31 AM

Yes, UGA's law school is diverse--just like when HBCU graduate schools are filled with nonblacks. In such instances the graduate applicants are not representative of the larger university or its surroundings.

Not having black people doesn't make a place not ethnically diverse if there is a representation of other racial and ethnic minority groups. However, in North America people think in terms of black and white (and Hispanic). If the largest (Hispanic) and second largest (Black) minority groups in America aren't substantially represented on certain campuses, of course the place will be viewed as not racially and ethnically diverse.

shinerbock 09-15-2006 11:20 AM

But its important to note that just because a place is overwhelmingly white does not make it homogeneous. White people are from a lot of different backgrounds obviously, we're all just lumped into a single category.

DSTCHAOS 09-15-2006 11:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321265)
But its important to note that just because a place is overwhelmingly white does not make it homogeneous. White people are from a lot of different backgrounds obviously, we're all just lumped into a single category.

LOL. Of course whites are not homogeneous. No group is, although we can always make generalizations based on the norms of a particular context.

But you all were specifically talking about racial and ethnic diversity. White people are lumped into one category racially and ethnically because white people have chosen to assimilate into one category--as opposed to remaining distinctly Italian American, Polish American, Irish American, etc.

The link I provided has information on demographic breakdowns beyond race and ethnicity because I know that diversity is a broad category. Many Universities boast about being diverse, but they are only talking about the diverse backgrounds of their white students (most often social class and region). :)

shinerbock 09-15-2006 12:17 PM

And I think that diversity within groups of white people is no less advantageous than racial diversity. I mean, black people and white people growing up in the same area under similar conditions are likely to bring similar things to the table. Meanwhile a white kid like me, and a white kid from Berkley whose parents lobby for PETA are likely to bring very distinctive viewpoints and experiences. I fail to see that black people, simply because they're black, bring something more to a university. I imagine that a white kid from New Mexico probably would bring more diversity to UGA than a black kid from Decatur, but I think schools get too caught up on how diversity looks in the Princeton Review breakdown.

33girl 09-15-2006 12:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321308)
And I think that diversity within groups of white people is no less advantageous than racial diversity. I mean, black people and white people growing up in the same area under similar conditions are likely to bring similar things to the table. Meanwhile a white kid like me, and a white kid from Berkley whose parents lobby for PETA are likely to bring very distinctive viewpoints and experiences. I fail to see that black people, simply because they're black, bring something more to a university. I imagine that a white kid from New Mexico probably would bring more diversity to UGA than a black kid from Decatur, but I think schools get too caught up on how diversity looks in the Princeton Review breakdown.

I agree.

And as far as white people "assimililating" into one group, it depends where you are - there are still people around here who identify themselves as ____-American and are very immersed in the culture.

Drolefille 09-15-2006 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 33girl (Post 1321332)
I agree.

And as far as white people "assimililating" into one group, it depends where you are - there are still people around here who identify themselves as ____-American and are very immersed in the culture.

Ditto.

I'm Italian-American (as well as just plain American) and I have a Nonna instead of a grandma. I can make pasta al dente and I know that the whole throwing it at the wall thing is bunk. It should always stick to the wall, but only taste will tell you if it's done.

But I also see myself as "American."

DSTCHAOS 09-15-2006 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321308)
I mean, black people and white people growing up in the same area under similar conditions are likely to bring similar things to the table.

Conventional wisdom would say "yes" but research indicates that whiteness generates cultural and social capital and (in general) gives the white people some advantage. This is because when the common denominator is human capital (what we bring to the table), what propels people to the top will be racial differentials in cultural capital (valued identifiers like race, speech, style of dress, etc.) and social capital (who you know/networks). In general, this propelling has occurred when the white person is connected to a white person in a blue collar hiring position or gets access to a suit and instructions for entering the labor market.

Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321308)
Meanwhile a white kid like me, and a white kid from Berkley whose parents lobby for PETA are likely to bring very distinctive viewpoints and experiences.

Yes, differing viewpoints and experiences are all over the place. The true test is in determining whether the different viewpoints and experiences translate to substantially different capital investments and returns. You and the Berkley student are likely to have similar capital investments and returns despite other surface differences. :) Now if there are social class differences, you or the Berkley kid will have some catching up to do.


Quote:

Originally Posted by shinerbock (Post 1321308)
I fail to see that black people, simply because they're black, bring something more to a university. I imagine that a white kid from New Mexico probably would bring more diversity to UGA than a black kid from Decatur, but I think schools get too caught up on how diversity looks in the Princeton Review breakdown.

Where have you been looking? ;)

There are commonalities across race, gender, region, class groups, etc. They do not have to translate to things that are observable on the surface level.

DSTCHAOS 09-15-2006 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 33girl (Post 1321332)
I agree.

And as far as white people "assimililating" into one group, it depends where you are - there are still people around here who identify themselves as ____-American and are very immersed in the culture.

No, it doesn't matter where you are. These groups are classified as white ethnic groups for a reason.

There are still people who identify as ______ by choice but many of these people identify as ________ situationally/contextually. You won't find too many of these people say "No, I'm not white, I'm Italian American." In other words, these people are well aware of their "whiteness" and the advantages associated with "whiteness" within a larger context.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:57 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.