Thanks guys! I was thinking along the marinade & herbs line. Molasses is a good one too!
I just wasn't totally sure what all is appropriate since he does already own things obviously. I picked up a skewers & a new set of tongs (at bfs request, says his dad is always misplacing his somehow) and I will probably pick up some marinades tomorrow when I go shopping.

Okay, brother-in-law's new girlfriend. We're celebrating with my in-laws over new years and we've been informed that she'll be joining us. I have no idea what to get her. She's 18 and waiting tables with no intentions of going to college (my MIL said "she seems (pause) fun..."). Apparently my 24 year old brother-in-law met her at a bar a few months ago:rolleyes:.
Any ideas?

Charming Charlies has cashmere scarfs for $20. Any woman that wouldn't want a cashmere scarf is really not a woman. If you don't want to spend that much, they have Pashmina's for $10.

Forever 21 gift card? Scarf/jewelry from there? That's personal while still being slightly impersonal.

I like the jewelry from forever21 idea. Depending on her age.
If she's out of her teens/early 20s then I'd go with bath and body works lotions or something