Now see, it's the opposite for me! Lindsay is the mean one whereas Hilary is just a kid...harmless.

But Hilary's acting is atrocious!

Oh - I don't know! They're both babies so I shouldn't even been saying negative things! Ok - love 'em both just the same!!

I think Hilary is better and so does my guy friends too!!!

Lohan, bigger boobs...heard she gives anal

Hillary Duff is much hotter!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

EWWW. wtf.

anyway, my vote goes to Lindsay, shes def. a better actress more versitel with more talent and everything. i dont like however how both hilary and now lindsay are trying to do the whole singing career....hella annoying!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

to me hilary seems more fake. i mean all she did was the lizzie mcguire role and thats it.

I bet Lindsey Lohan's father could kick Hillary Duff's father's a$$. After all, he got arrested for beating up one of his brothers.

i think Hillary is fun. My love for her acting stopped at "Lizzie McGuire". I kinda want her album though.

Anywho, I pick Lindsay. She seems cooler. I love her movies and I think that she has a good singing voice. I am interested in hearing her upcoming album.

It sounds like she definitely comes from an interesting family. That might be part of her edge and what makes her come across as a pretty down girl. Hillary seems a little more giggly and girly.

Hillary Duff, hands down.

Lindsay Lohan....if I were 16 I'd probably want to be her. Except the black version. :rolleyes: :D :p